Vegan
American
Pizza
Italian
Delivery
Take-out
3 Brothers offers several branches across Long Island. This one opened in 2015 is the all-vegan version. Has extensive vegan menu created by one of the sons, Jay, that features many choices, from pizza with vegan cheese & mock meats to burgers, hoagies, pasta, and other Italian entrees. Brunch menu on Sundays. Reported closed October 2023.
© OpenStreetMap contributors
-
Loading...
-
- Accepts credit cards
-
-
Last update on 27 Dec 2023 by RebeccaSullivan
Update business info -
Are you the owner?
Claim this business
-
-
67 Reviews
First Review by slo0go
mel2427
Points +17
Delicious food - Edit
Have taken the 25 minute drive many times, totally worth it. Favorite pizzas are the eggplant, grandma, and Bianco. Also love the Buffalo cauliflower!
Read moreGuest
warde4
Points +94
A classic Italian restaurant...that happens to be entirely vegan! - Edit
Long Island isn’t known for its vegan restaurants. In fact, 3 Brothers touts itself as its only one. But my love of 3 Brothers is not out of a lack of alternatives. What makes 3 Brothers great is that it is a truly authentic Long Island Italian restaurant and pizzeria.
Read moreAfter a glance at its menu, one wouldn’t be remiss for wondering if they’ve accidentally stumbled into the wrong place. Mozzarella sticks, arancini, calamari, baked ziti, and spaghetti and meatballs are all featured menu items. And they are delicious. The staff are all friendly and welcoming, and the prices are reasonable.
3 Brothers does an amazing job of veganizing every Italian restaurant staple. The familiarity of their menu makes it a great place to bring skeptical non-vegans unfamiliar with the very concept of cashew milk cheese or seitan. This is the very first vegan restaurant I took my family to, and it’s so great because even the most diehard omnivores can feel right at home and not intimidated.
I regularly drive over an hour to visit this restaurant, and though I sure wish there were more vegan restaurants on Long Island, I’m so glad that one we have is 3 Brothers.
Pros: Familiar menu items, Reasonable prices, Awesome staff
Guest
Cmhawk3
Points +23
One of the few all vegan spots on Long Island. - Edit
The food was not bad. The desserts are amazing! The grandma’s pizza is delicious. I wish that they sold large pizzas instead of small or personal ones. Other than that, the food was overall pretty good. They also have a brunch menu on Sundays! I would definitely will be back!
Read more10/10
Pros: Cute atmosphere , Delicious food
Cons: It can be a little expensive.
Guest
FellyGaga
Points +28
Yummy! - Edit
Been a fan of the Farmingdale location for a few years now being that I live around the block. But finally ventured to the Copaigue location which is 100% vegan. The food is amazing, service was on point and they have more options than Farmingdale. My husband (non-vegan but dabbling into the vegan world) was raving about everything from the rice balls to his Bolognese dinner to our amazing dessert! Can’t wait to come back!
Read morePros: 100% Vegan, Italian, Delicious
Guest
gabandtonic
Points +3052
3 brothers always delivers! - Edit
Such a great joint. I am obsessed with their truffle aioli. I do wish they had wings at this location as they do in Farmingdale
Read moreGuest
hcaseycrucilla
Points +16
Great vegan food - Edit
We used to enjoy eating in the restaurant and now with COVID, we enjoy getting take out. The full menu is available, the portions are generous and the food was hot and delicious.
Read moreGuest
Krabecal
Points +65
Amazing - Edit
I drive an hour for the ziti ... that’s about sums it up😄
Read moreMac and cheese balls and mozz sticks are also out of this world.
Guest
JennaRose
Points +21
Great food and ambiance - Edit
Love coming here! Love the Bianca pizza
Read morePros: Great service, Even better dessert
Guest
KarenM
Points +74
Best vegan pizza ever - Edit
As someone raised on Long Island I really missed classic NY pizza when I became vegan. You can get personal artisan vegan pies but it is harder to find classic pizza. This place does it! The pizza is amazing and the other food is also delicious (I tend to default to pizza since I don't live close by and I love it so much.) Cannolis are also delicious! I have eaten there a couple of times but usually do takeout. Even my parents who are extremely suspicious of vegan food (and are born and bred New Yorkers) like this pizza.
Read moreGuest
AshleyNLaxton
Points +18
My favorite! - Edit
Most of there food is really good. I was amazed by the calamari. The mac and cheese balls are also very good. I live having a place to go where I can order anything on the menu.
Read morePros: All vegan at copaige location
Guest
courtneyautera
Points +144
Incredible vegan Italian food - Edit
This is my favorite vegan Italian restaurant of all time. They serve high-quality food and when I eat out with non-vegan friends or family members, they can’t even tell the food is different. I also have to mention that the desserts are amazing! The staff are very kind and truly care about the customers. However, I do wish they served slices of pizza because you can only order a pie.
Read morePros: Delicious food, Amazing staff, Variety of options
Cons: Expensive, Doesn’t offer individual slices of pizza
Guest
MariasantaBellucci
Points +22
Absolutely Delicious - Edit
This restaurant is incredible. Classic Italian fare with an enormous menu and the entire place is Vegan. A very happy place including the customers and staff. Prices are very reasonable and the dining room is cozy and comfortable. This place is not to be missed!
Read moreGuest
adrianaRL00
Points +46
This place was amazing - Edit
This place was great everything on the menu could be made vegan the pizza and pasta reminded me of real cheesy and chicken Italian meals I had before becoming vegan
Read morePros: Lots of vegan option , Everything on menu can be made vegan , Nice staff clean
Cons: Small eating are better for takeout but I didn’t
Guest
eravencroft
Points +173
wonderfully accommodating and warmly welcoming. - Edit
can't remember the last time i received a handshake upon entering a restaurant. from the moment we arrived till exiting we were treated to a fresh, fabulous, inventive and wholesome italian meal to remember by a top notch wait staff. we ordered a ton of food and had plenty to take away for a post jones beach concert snack and leftovers the next day. i can say nothing but good things about the cauliflower wings, pesto linguini, orecchiette with sausage and broccoli rabe, kale salad, and fried mac n cheese balls. the vegan cheeses and meats appear to all be made in house and were a refreshing change from the processed ready made "garden variety" alternatives i've become accustomed to. this is real italian food made vegan with a wonderful attention to whole foods, using simple ingredients and just the right amount of preparation. my only regret is feeling a little rushed to get to a concert and not being able to stretch the meal out for another couple hours!
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2019-09-26
Pros: friendliest service i've received in ages, authentic italian dishes (+ a few comfort foods), house made vegan meats and cheeses
Cons: the ambience could use a little jazzing up, i didn't get to try their pizza!
Guest
PaulineJettie-Jaballa
Points +20
The best vegan food I have had! - Edit
Super friendly staff first of all!
Read moreI come from the San Francisco area, and vegan food is pretty good there but this is hands down the best spot I have come across! I am in food heaven! God is goooood!
Guest
YohanⓋ
Points +6767
Huge pizza, amazing wings! - Edit
The large pizza was way bigger than a family size back home is Australia! Not bad either, but the buffalo wings, wow! Amazing! And the service was spot on too!
Read morePros: Delicious buffalo wings, Huge size pizzas, Great service
Guest
tracylynn
Points +40
Love this place - Edit
I visit here frequently. The staff is amazing and very friendly. The food is beyond good.
Read moreGuest
Christinaguzman
Points +47
I loved it - Edit
I went as a recommendation from a friend and i was not disappointed. The food was so good. It made me happy that there were so many vegan options to eat there. I highly recommend getting some vegan dessert.
Read morePros: excellent food, friendly staff, love the decor
Guest
joannedv
Points +20
Excellent! - Edit
The food here is beyond good! The waitress was friendly and the prices are reasonable. I would highly recommend this restaurant.
Read moreGuest
Vicmaine
Points +94
Awesome Totally Vegan Meal! - Edit
We met family at the 3 Brothers Vegan Cafe tonight 12/7/18 and it is in business! Thank Goodness! I ate a delicious and huge Caesar salad with a pasta dish then finished that off with desert, a chocolate canolli cake - it all was delicious and totally vegan! I was so impressed and overjoyed to have found this oasis of vegan food.
Read morePros: Totally Vegan, Friendly, 100% Vegan
Cons: Not any in my area in Maine :(
Guest
RachelHS
Points +132
Spot on homemade Italian favorites! - Edit
So many delicious choices! The cheeses are amazing, staff is super friendly. Great portions too!
Read moreGuest
hapyandhealthyvegan
Points +32
Good pizza place - Edit
I like this place, they have a bunch of vegan options. The whole place is vegan so it makes it easy.
Read morePros: Lots of vegan options , Awesome vegan cheesecake , Nice people
Cons: Little pricy , Brunch menu needs to expand
Guest
prbemevegan
Points +1115
Great food and service - Edit
We had a great dinner experience at 3 Brothers. So many delicious options to choose from and served in large portions. The staff was super friendly and attentive. There was 7 in our party, 4 vegans and 3 vegetarians. We were all happy with our orders. They brought out warm bread and butter to our tables when we first arrived. This bread was so delicious! For appetizers we ordered: calamari mushrooms, buffalo cauliflower wings and Mac n cheese balls. The Mac n cheese balls were just ok. For our entrees we had baked ziti, lasagna, bacon cheeseburger with fries, cheese pie, and cauliflower steak. Everything was delicious! For dessert we got Death by Chocolate cake, Cookies and Cream cake, Peanut butter bomb cake, and a cannoli. They were all so good, especially the Death by Chocolate. So happy they make cashew cheese and not just throw on Daiya, although they do have it if you want it. It's available upon request. We'll definitely return
Read morePros: Lots of vegan options , Great staff and service, House made cashew cheese not Daiya
Cons: None
Guest
Katie Le
Points +553
Fantastic options w homemade cheese - Edit
So Many wonderful options! I was really pleasantly surprised to find that they use homemade cultured cheese from nuts and not just Daiya. The pizza was great, we also got lasagna, eggplant Parmesan, ravioli etc etc. lots of food for carry-out for a hungry large group.
Read moreGuest
BoxerLover
Points +41
Great Food - Edit
I love it here! I drive from Queens just to eat here or order take out.
Read moreMy favorites are the polenta fries with an extra side of sauce, and the grilled tofu pesto panini with French fries. I've had other items, pizza, calzones, and they were also really good. Next for me to try will be the pasta and eggplant dishes.
The cheesecakes are awesome!
Pros: Enjoyed everything I've tried so far., Very nice, large menu selection, I'm loving vegan ITALIAN food!
Cons: Long drive for me, but worth it
Guest
OliviaMarie
Points +167
Pleased my omni friends! - Edit
Enjoyed an awesome dinner with some non-veg friends here. The portion sizes were generous and the food was yummy! The desserts were a little pricey and I'd already stuffed myself so I passed, but they looked INCREDIBLE, I hope I can come back soon to try some. Servers were very kind and helpful. Just a PSA, parking can be tricky.
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2018-01-13
Pros: Unique find!, Huge menu, Has brunch!
Cons: Parking is limited/tight
Guest
beetsd0ntkalemyvibe
Points +106
give them a shot - Edit
The first time we went here we were disappointed. The service wasn’t great and neither was our pesto pasta. We decided to give it another chance and have now been back multiple times since and I live quite far. Is their service the best? No. But they’re not rude or anything like that. Some of their dishes aren’t the best, but others are a home run. I love their penne alla vodka, mozzarella sticks, all their pizzas, and Mac n cheese. They’re one of the only completely vegan restauarants on Long Island, so I’m happy to support them.
Read morePros: “cheese” in mozzarella sticks is actually gooey an, all vegan, good desserts
Cons: can be hit or miss, service isn’t the best, also not the worst
Guest
For Members
Why was my review removed? Guidelines for writing a review View our privacy policyFor Business Owners
Claim this business See inaccurate information? Submit an update here Link to this page from your site See an unfair review? View full terms & conditionsThis page has been viewed 0 times.