• Trenary Toast Cafe

  • (7)
    3
    Loading...
  • White Veg-options
Lacto
Ovo
American
Delivery
Take-out
Honey
Breakfast
Non-veg

Serves meat, vegan options available. Cafe offering a few vegan items such as tomato soup, avocado toast, vegan BLT, vegan bacon melt, and beverages with non-dairy milks. Open Mon-Fri 7:30am-4:00pm, Sat 7:30am-5:00pm, Sun 8:00am-3:00pm.


7 Reviews

First Review by EverydayTastiness

nikoleclarke

Points +261

Vegan
23 Sep 2025

Vegan options that will offend your tastebuds

I ordered their vegan melt and my husband ordered one of their breakfast sandwiches, the Harlow Lake Sunrise Sammy made vegan. They say they have food for all diets, but that doesn't mean it's good.

My melt was...weird. It was vegan cheddar cheese, vegan mayo, vegan cream cheese, vegan bacon, tomato, and diced jalapeno. It was visually unappealing and it was too goopy. The assortment of cheeses and condiments did not make sense, and the diced jalapenos don't make sense on a sandwich.

The unmodified breakfast sandwich has red pepper hummus, fried egg, feta, cucumber, tomato, and spring mix. On the menu, it says it can be vegan for $1.50. His sandwich came out with hummus, cucumber, tomato, and spring mix with a slice of vegan cheddar. There was no replacement for the egg and the feta was replaced with cheddar. Why did we pay extra to have less? Also, the hashbrown that came with the sandwich was soggy and it tasted like fish.

YayVegan2017

Points +211

Vegan
21 May 2025

Vegan Melt Okay

They had two vegan options: one spicy and non-spicy. The Vegan Melt looked good, I don’t think the bacon agreed with my stomach. I’m not always the biggest fan of mock meats from a restaurant. I was also a little bummed that they had no vegan cinnamon roll option.

Pros: Two vegan options, Great coffee w/ oat milk, The environment was cute and the workers friendly

Cons: The bacon didn’t agree with me. , Cost

RamaniSharana

Points +77

Vegetarian
18 May 2025

I would give 5 stars but this app won't let me

This place is amazing. The drinks are good and most can be vegan. We love all the vegan choices here including the vegan BLT ( it's not on the menu but they have it...ask for it it's amazing). The staff is so friendly and fun. The atmosphere is cozy. And you can earn points for free things so that's cool!

Pros: Food -lots of choices, Atmosphere, Staff

Cons: Wish there were more vegan desserts

Beanybb

Points +16

Vegan
10 Aug 2023

Vegan lunch

Lots of vegetarian options and a few vegan too. I had a Blueberry Matcha and a vegan BLT on rye breAd. Happy to find a place that had options besides veggie burgers for lunch.

Thevegheas

Points +13

Vegetarian
10 Aug 2023

Great vegetarian options

Cute shop with a lot of vegetarian options, even a Vegan BLT. Enjoyed the avocado toast and the VBLT.

Updated from previous review on 2023-08-10

fontenot

Points +158

Vegan
29 Jul 2023

Staff says "we don't have vegan cheese slices", puts dairy cheese on a vegan sandwich instead

My recent experience at Trenary Toast was the one of the more bizarre encounters I've had at a restaurant in the 10 years I've been vegan.

At first this looks like a great place to eat in Marquette. The menu labels vegetarian items (with a leaf symbol), and describes another symbol (cow) as "vegetarian or vegan possible". This is *not* the case. Most of the items highlighted with a cow are not even potentially vegan. If you want to eat vegan here, you will need to ask about everything in your particular sandwich, including the bread options.

Unfortunately the staff isn't likely to be helpful. We ordered two sandwiches and specifically requested "the vegan option". They gave both of us sandwiches with dairy cheese on them. When we asked what had happened, they said that Trenary Toast "does not have vegan cheese slices", and the option shown on the menu is to make the sandwiches *vegetarian* instead. In this case that meant that our "vegan" sandwiches had multiple meats substituted with a single alternative (vegan bacon), and the dairy cheese left on it.

The menu isn't even consistent on this point. If (as stated by the staff) the cow symbol meant that the sandwich was "vegetarian *OR* vegan possible" (but not necessarily both), then every vegetarian sandwich on the menu should have had the cow logo. But this is not the case - the grilled cheese is vegetarian but has no cow, for example. That certainly makes the menu more confusing for a hapless vegan who happens to wander in. Apparently they have both non-vegan (vegetarian) bacon as well as vegan bacon, so that's another issue to watch out for.

I wouldn't bother with this place.

EverydayTastiness

Points +2744

Vegan
04 Jul 2023

Great!

Great drinks. The cinnamon, smore chai was amazing. We also loved the cinnamon bread from the rack in back.




This page has been viewed 0 times.