• The Kaatskeller

  • (5)
  • White Veg-options

Serves meat, vegan options available. Uses locally produced product. Vegan choices include kale caesar salad, pizza with house-made vegan cheese, and oat milk gelato. Other dishes may possibly be modified to be made vegan - ask. Open Wed 5:00pm-9:00pm, Fri-Sat 5:00pm-9:00pm, Sat 12:00pm-4:00pm, Sun 12:00pm-7:30pm.

Venue map for The Kaatskeller
© OpenStreetMap contributors

5 Reviews

First Review by jupitergeek


Points +1404

15 Jul 2023

Yummy vegan pizza

Really cool place with nice outdoor seating and communal tables. We had yummy vegan pizzas! The staff were happy and helpful!

Pros: Cute outdoor seating



Points +100

28 May 2022

Great setting for brick oven 'za

Pizzas can be made with vegan cheese (I think it's from Cheezehound, a local vegan cheese creamery), we had the margherita pie. The delicious Caesar salad is vegan by default with vegan dressing, vegan parm, and spicy chickpeas.

Pros: Pizzas can be made with vegan cheese, Friendly staff, Cool setting


Points +114

05 Apr 2022

Hip Cozy Vibe

We had the vegan caesar salad and the Mediterranean Retreat pizza subbed with vegan Cheezehound mozz cheese. Both were delicious. They have a small bar upstairs and music on Friday nights. Everyone was super friendly and accommodating and happy to make sure our food was made vegan. They have a beautiful outdoor dining area and we sat by the fire pit for awhile. It was a chilly night but the summers must be amazing there. Hope to get back in warmer days and try the oat milk gelato from Milkweed, the ice cream trailer that I hear opens in summer.

Pros: Friendly staff, Good amount of vegan options, Great atmosphere

Cons: They also serve meat


Points +314

07 Nov 2021

Good vegan wood-fired pizza

10/31/21 Have been back to eat more pizza — and very much enjoyed! Pricey if ordering one pie per person but absolutely delicious. Got the Mediterranean Retreat ($19) with kalamata olives, spinach, white onions, EVOO and sun dried tomatoes but asked for without feta. Arrived at table *with* cheese but like 10 seconds afterward one of the ladies showed up and swapped out for mine without feta exclaiming she did remember and quickly apologized, I was so happy I didn’t need to wait as I was pretty hungry and they were getting close to closing time! 🤗

Nice options, good cheese. Only been once, looking forward to the next visit. Very nice interior and exterior atmosphere.

Bonus option for vegan gelato with the streetside Milkweed Oatmilk Gelato truck right outside the front gate, where to go orders can be placed for Kaatskeller.

Updated from previous review on 2021-11-07

Pros: Atmosphere, Vegan options

Cons: Vegan options not well listed on online menu, 8 sprigs of $ basil on pie


Points +571

27 Aug 2021

Pizza was really good, unique and cool spot

Ordered from the cool little trailer, amazing vegan in house made cheese, friendly and helpful staff, great drinks, and the outdoor patio space was wonderful. Sadly they had no oat milk ice cream when we came despite us being there when they opened. Best vegan pizza I’ve had in a long time. Fun experience on our way to a concert at Bethel Woods.

This page has been viewed 985 times.