• Screamin' Mimi's

  • (3)
    3
    Loading...
  • Ice-cream Ice Cream

Ice cream shop with a few vegan ice creams and some vegan waffle cones. Open Mon-Thu 11:30am-9:30pm, Fri-Sat 11:30am-10:00pm, Sun 11:30am-9:30pm. Closed Thanksgiving and Christmas Day.


Venue map for Screamin' Mimi's
© OpenStreetMap contributors

3 Reviews

First Review by Forman

Forman

Points +6284

Vegan
18 Jan 2025

Yummy ice cream ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Been here before. Today came and had vegan mud. Wow was that good! A few other choices on hand.

Never heard of ice cream being made with lentil milk.

Vegan Mimi's Mud
Made with lentil milk (V)(GF)

Updated from previous review on 2023-04-15

ScreaminMimi

18 Jan 2025

Hello hello, I am the owner of Screamin’ Mimi’s. I take a lot of pride in our vegan Mimi’s mud. It has taken quite a while to develop that flavor. Your review says.” wow, was that good!”…. and yet we get four out of five stars. As I said to a previous reviewer, if you want people to offer good tasting vegan options, you might want to be generous with their reviews. That would encourage more people to come and buy the product that you like rather than me, deciding not to sell it because not enough people are buying it because we’ve only got an average of 3 1/2 stars on the vegan website.

Forman

18 Jan 2025

Hey Owner of Screamin' Mimi's!

On Happy Cow a place that is not 100% vegan can not get a 5 star review. Obviously a 4 star is the best they will get.


I edited my review Title with 5 stars.
Thanks for having yummy vegan flavors for us.

ScreaminMimi

25 Jan 2025

Thanks for the info, I had no idea. Not sure why they can’t just distinguish vegan and not vegan in a different fashion, but I get it.

dhall22

Points +465

Vegan
12 Jul 2024

Great place, limited vegan options

Screamin Mimi's is an institution in Sebastopol. I'm really glad they now have some vegan flavors, and what they have were very good. I really liked Mimi's Mud and Mint Chocolate Chip. However, they only have about 4 vegan flavors compared to probably 12 dairy flavors. And even some flavors listed online weren't available when we showed up. Hope they continue to expand.
They're also open pretty late in the summer until 10pm.

Pros: Good vegan ice cream, Friendly plce

Cons: Limited flavors, Inconsistent availability

ScreaminMimi

18 Jan 2025

Hello, thank you for the review but I would like to point out that we are an ice cream shop. Since we opened in 1995 we have always offered 16 dairy based ice cream creams and eight non-dairy sorbets. That is 1/3 of our options are vegan. That’s a pretty large percentage for an ice cream shop.

AnitaH

Points +482

Vegan
03 Aug 2023

So many vegan flavors to choose from!

I had the orange lavender sorbet which weirdly tasted like a delicious lotion. Not terribly sweet. My friend had the vegan strawberry which also was well balanced and not too sweet.

ScreaminMimi

18 Jan 2025

I am the owner of Screamin’ Mimi’s. I appreciate your review, but please keep in mind, we are an ice cream shop. We opened 30 years ago and have been serving 16 dairy based ice cream flavors and eight ( non-dairy) sorbet since the day we opened. That’s one third of our offerings that are vegan since 1995.. We have changed from only fruit sorbets to include non-dairy creamy frozen desserts. Your review says everything was very good yet you give us three stars because you think we need more than 8 options (???). . If you want businesses to serve nondairy products, you might want to review them higher so that other people go there and try their non-dairy products and make it worth our while to continue to make those items.

AnitaH

18 Jan 2025

Hi! I gave you a 4 star review which is the highest I can do on this platform because you are not a fully vegan place. I also noted in my title that you have so many vegan options to choose from. Not sure why you are responding this way but my review was a good one - nothing to be upset about!

ScreaminMimi

25 Jan 2025

Thank you very much. I had no idea that this site does not allow five stars to places that are not 100% vegan. I did not mean to be in any way negative. It’s just I don’t understand when somebody gives a great review and loves the place and then 4 stars …generally that’s a five star review. As a business owner it is really important to my bottom line to maintain really high ratings. We care very much about it. Not being able to achieve. The highest rating is very disappointing.. I completely understand its because of the platform. Thank you.




This page has been viewed 576 times.