Welcome! Let's get this started.
or
Finish logging in.
-
Jay's Artisan Pizzeria
-
Loading...
-
Veg Options
Vegan-friendly
Lacto
Pizza
Italian
Take-out
Non-veg
Serves meat, vegan options available. Pizzeria offering Neapolitan and Detroit-style pizzas, with vegan cheese available as a standard topping option. Open Tue-Sat 4:00pm-8:00pm. Closed Sun & Mon.
-
Loading...
-
- Accepts credit cards
-
-
Last update on 15 Sep 2026 by Guest
Update business info -
Are you the owner?
Claim this business -
Added by BuffaloVegan on 15 Sep 2026
-
-
1 Review
First Review by BuffaloVegan
BuffaloVegan
Points +438
14th Best Pizza in the World - Edit
The pizza and service are exceptional.
Read moreI had heard there were vegan options but didn't see anything on the website. Their sister pizzeria, Pizza Florian in East Aurora, had a separate vegan menu so I was hoping for the same. That is not the case here.
Our server said any pizza could be made vegan, meaning they could swap out the cheese for vegan cheese but any other non-vegan items (meat, specially cheeses like stracciatella) would be omitted. That's fine, though not ideal. Same with the $2.50 upcharge for vegan cheese- makes sense all other things being equal but if whole ingredients are being left off, it adds to the sting of not getting a similar experience for thoughtful seasonal pies.
In the end, the pizza is so delicious it's hard not to give 5 stars. We had a Neopolitan and a Detroit style. The dough on both was incredible and magical and really the star of the pizza. The vegan cheese is great - did not remind me of any common store brands. The toppings accent the crust rather than the crust being just a vehicle for toppings.
Lots of seasonal items, so go often.
There is no phone and no reservations. Inside gets busy. Open until 8pm or sold out.
Pros: All pizzas can be made vegan , Dough is amazing, Unique Seasonal Items
Cons: Must be omit rather than swap some ingredients, $2.50 for vegan cheese
Guest
For Members
Why was my review removed? Guidelines for writing a review View our privacy policyFor Business Owners
Claim this business See inaccurate information? Submit an update here Link to this page from your site See an unfair review? View full terms & conditionsThis page has been viewed 52 times.