Lacto
American
Pizza
Italian
Fast food
Delivery
Take-out
Catering
Gluten-free
Non-veg
Serves meat, vegan options available. Offers a separate vegan menu with American-style pizzas with vegan cheese, a range of fried appetizers, pasta, salad, hot & cold subs as well as desserts. Nov '22 - reported not not fully vegan as shares a kitchen space with a non-veg restaurant. Open Mon-Sun 10:00am-12:00am.
© OpenStreetMap contributors
-
9 Whitney Ave, New Haven, Connecticut, USA, 06510
-
Loading...
-
- Accepts credit cards
-
-
Last update on 13 Feb 2023 by costapizza
Update business info -
Added by costapizza on 10 May 2022
-
-
15 Reviews
First Review by iloveveganicecream
kidatheart6
Points +46
A must visit - Edit
The food is beyond excellent. The staff are wonderful. My wife and I love it here.
Read morePros: Food, Service , Vegan options
Guest
SirElfman
Points +78
Great vegan Italian food - Edit
A wonderful little restaurant that has vegan options and is halal. The sausage and peppers with penne was outstanding and my wife loved her cheese ravioli. Chocolate cake was tasty
Read morePros: Tasty, LOTS of vegan options
Cons: A bit pricey, but typical for the area
Guest
hohuho
Points +44
Incredibly overpriced, underwhelming food - Edit
They have an extensive vegan menu, so we ordered a few things while on a roadtrip. I should’ve trusted my gut and walked out when I saw the $26 pricetag for one plate of pasta. Would not be surprised if they prepared it with a jar of sauce off a store counter. Tiny space with no bathroom for customers, which is wild considering I dropped $80 on some ragu on spaghetti with some Aldi meatballs and two other similarly bad dishes. One of the weirdest dining experiences of my life, no clue how they have a full 4 stars for a non-vegan place. Must’ve gone downhill recently.
Read morePros: Large menu
Cons: Way overpriced , No flavor, No public restroom
kidatheart6
I think the a 1 is a bit harsh. I can see giving less than a 3. I
Read moreGuest
Kwr_
Points +1123
Excellent vegan section inside Costa Pizzeria - Edit
Separate vegan section inside Costa Pizzeria. Lots of options for classic New Haven style pizza, calzones, pasta, wraps, salas, subs, and wings. My favourite thing we tried was the pesto chicken pizza, but the buffalo wings were a close second.
Read moreGuest
vegonugs
Points +1714
nice for a quick bite - Edit
very small space, can hear staff talking very loudly while trying to eat… wish it was fully vegan but it shares a kitchen with non veg, a bit confusing like is bella casa a separate owner? food was okay… and hard to find street parking
Read moreGuest
brandeexv
Points +576
Large menu - Edit
Inside a pizza shop with its own vegan menu, a decent sized menu. The turkey and cheese was good just wished it was more filled or had pickles. The garlic knots were fire too !
Read moreGuest
VegDragon
Points +13
Sausage and Peppers - Edit
Did not realize this menu was inside of Casta Pizza. Had the sausage and peppers hot sub. Have not had sausage and peppers in a long time. The taste almost took me back to the San Gennaro Feast celebrations in NY. It was delicious. Red Velvet Cake was moist and delicious. Nice vibe.
Read morePros: Lots of Vegan options
Cons: Pricey
Guest
E1yza
Points +226
Garlic knots were the highlight - Edit
I had the penne alla vodka, chicken parm sub, and garlic knots. It was good to try but i wouldn’t get the penne alla vodka again
Read moreGuest
natalia11691
Points +554
really great pizza - Edit
tastes just how i remember real pizza tasting like… i also took him some slices of vegan cake! excellent.
Read moreGuest
lizfrancis14
Points +185
location is great - Edit
walkable from both Yale’s University and hospital— seems to be a frequented restaurant by that crowd. there’s a good amount of fried food which isn’t my personal favorite but has a wide variety of options that aren’t. amazing vegan pizza here, large portions
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2022-11-01
Guest
Scribb11
Points +259
Tasty vegan food - Edit
We needed something quick whilst passing though New Haven and found this gem hidden in Costa Pizza.
Read morePros: Loads of choice , Nice staff, Very tasty
Cons: Hidden inside so not able to see until close up
Guest
KileyOBrien
Points +358
Worth the 30minute drive - Edit
We had the chicken parm sub and it was amazing! I’ve been wanting something like that since I went vegan 8 years ago. We also tried the mash potatoe and bacon pizza which was so good! And to finish it off the cheesecake and red velvet cake were to die for.
Read moreGuest
Amyladedada1
Points +658
Fine in a pinch - Edit
Da Legna was closed. We were looking for some vegan pizza. We found this spot! A really nice amount of options. I could see college kids loving it for some late night bites.
Read moreMy major concern were the prices that were a bit inflated in comparison to meat and dairy options. And they used common things we could buy in a store like their Buffalo Wings were the gardein ones- which isn’t bad, just not what I was looking for. Not my jam but could h be e someone else’s.
Pros: Lots of options, Quick, Friendly
Cons: Expensive
Guest
LauraL22
Points +77
Lots of great options - Edit
Have ordered take out from here several times and have not been disappointed! The buffalo chicken wrap and quesadilla were both excellent. The steak and cheese wrap and tuna sub were pretty good, as well as the cheese bread and fries. The crispy chicken salad was okay but probably would not order again.
Read morePros: Lots of vegan options, Good quality
Cons: On the pricier side
Guest
iloveveganicecream
Points +984
Costa Pizza’s Vegan Side - Edit
This is inside Costa Pizza. It’s not really a vegan restaurant. BBQ “chicken” pizza is good!
Read moreA different time, we tried the sausage & pepper sandwich and another hot sandwich and those were overly greasy.
Updated from previous review on 2022-06-13
Guest
For Members
Why was my review removed? Guidelines for writing a review View our privacy policyFor Business Owners
Claim this business
See inaccurate information? Submit an update here Link to this page from your site See an unfair review? View full terms & conditionsThis page has been viewed 4829 times.