• 5 Borough Bagels

  • (8)
  • White Veg-options
Fast food

Serves meat, vegan options available. New York Style bagel place with vegan bagels: spinach artichoke and cinnamon walnut. Could build your own bagel sandwich. Offers almond & oat milks. Peanut butter available. Open Mon-Fri 6:30am-3:00pm, Sat-Sun 8:00am-2:00pm.

Venue map for 5 Borough Bagels
© OpenStreetMap contributors

8 Reviews

First Review by shafess


Points +55

03 Dec 2023

Won’t return unless it’s to get bagels to go.

I would only go back to get bagels to go (to eat at home with a vegan cream cheese.)

My main reason for coming here was for their vegan cream cheese. They no longer offer it. They do have almond & oat milks for coffee drinks.

Ordered a pumpkin bagel with peanut butter. They gave me at least 1/4 cup p.b. Way too much. Bagel was tasty.

Also ordered a side of hash browns. OMG. They are WAY too heavy handed with the pepper. Too spicy. Couldn’t finish.

No salt available.

We ate “in”, they only have disposable utensils, etc. even if you’re not taking it to go.

Atmosphere and decor is nice. Convenient location.

Pros: Atmosphere, Location, Bagels

Cons: No longer offer vegan cream cheese, Hash browns were too spicy , Not environmentally friendly. Uses all disposables



Points +32

15 Oct 2023

No more vegan options

They got rid of all the vegan options.

Pros: Nothing

Cons: No options , Don’t waste your time or gas going there


Points +20

07 Sep 2023

Not vegan!!!

They could actually have some....

Pros: Nothing

Cons: They have completely removed their vegan options.


Points +62

11 May 2023

No more tofu cream cheese

If you frequent this place for their tofu cream cheese like I did, it is no more 😭


Points +45

20 Oct 2018


Very good, friendly staff and it’s refreshing to have a vegan bagel sandwich

Pros: Spinach tofu spread is amazing

Cons: Not a huge vegan variety


Points +66

26 Jun 2018


This place is pretty cool! I stopped by to grab a bagel sandwich.

The shop it is self it pretty cute, colorful and simple with nice decorations. I love all the seating they offer. When I came into the shop you can see the cream cheese displayed like ice cream is in a ice cream shop and I love they made that product front and center. The menus are large and very easy to read.

They have three vegan options for spread for your bagel or bagel sandwich, hummus, spinach artichoke tofu cream cheese and a cinnamon walnut tofu cream cheese option as well.



Points +222

12 Oct 2017

Good, but seemed unprepared for a morning rush

We got there around 10:30 on a Saturday morning, and almost all of the bagels were out already, so our options were limited. There were two tofu spreads--a cinnamon walnut and spinach artichoke (or something like that). I tried the spinach artichoke (because there weren't any bagels left that went with cinnamon walnut), and it was really good, though super garlicky. I tasted garlic for hours after.

We also ordered coffees, which can be made with nondairy milk for an upcharge. The place was pretty busy, but even with a lot of staff, it was slow. We finished out bagels before we even got our coffee.

Pros: Vegan "cream cheese" spread

Cons: Ran out of product, Slow service, Upcharge for vegan options


Points +600

10 Apr 2017


I was so excited when the tofu based spreads became available. I visited Madison, WI recently and they had a NY style bagel place with a tofu based cream cheese spread that was delicious. I requested to 5 Borough Bagels that they try something similar, and within a couple weeks, they did! Not saying it was entirely my doing, but either way, I'm happy. Both flavors are super delicious, and while I'd love for their everything bagel to be vegan (all seeded bagels have an egg-wash), the vegan bagels they do have are well made and tasty. Extremely friendly staff and cute vibe.

Pros: Great staff, Cute vibe, Delicious vegan spreads and bagels

Cons: Nothing!

This page has been viewed 2026 times.