• Potato Valley Cafe

  • (16)
  • White Veg-options

Serves meat, vegan options available. Baked potato restaurant. Around half of the menu is vegetarian and listed on a separate board. Will omit or substitute if asked. Salads and sandwiches also. Open Mon-Fri 11:00am-5:00pm, Sat 11:00am-4:00pm.

Venue map for Potato Valley Cafe
© OpenStreetMap contributors

16 Reviews

First Review by Naptown


Points +25

10 Apr 2023


The vegan option at this restaurant is so so so very good. The staff is so welcoming! I rarely feel inclined to write reviews but I love this place!

Pros: Delicious vegan option: Rustic Vegan Potato , Incredibly kind and quick service



Points +44

29 Nov 2022


The Rustic Vegan Potato is fantastic! This is awesome, with freshly made food that can accommodate specific requests or ingredient substitutions… Just speak up and ask for what you want!! They are incredibly kind and happy to serve.


Points +693

03 Jul 2022

Potatoes all day

A short scenic walk from the water and right across from the State House. Had the rustic vegan potato — cauliflower, roasted asparagus, lettuce, avocado, and many other goodies that made it a very tasty and filling lunch. Left off the oil and vegan butter. The staff are super friendly and helpful with the menu. Recommend and would go back.

Pros: Healthy options, Variety of toppings, Friendly staff


Points +30

26 Jun 2022

Loved the concept of a baked potato pour over restaurant. Food was delicious!

Packed with veggies and topped with fresh avocado.

Pros: Vegan options with added toppings , Friendly wait staff, let us sample the options


Points +37

29 Apr 2022

delicious potatoes

I absolutely adore Potato Valley! They have great vegan options for a good price (my favorite is the rustic potato). The staff is very friendly, and the environment is lovely. Make sure to ask for your potato to be made with olive oil instead of butter!

Pros: Delicious options, Good cost for what you get, Friendly staff


Points +108

15 Oct 2021

Delicious baked potatoes!

Fresh and tasty potatoes chock full of veggies.


Points +1197

15 Jul 2021

You say potato, I say feast!

I popped into this little potato shop after seeing it on happy cow and I was hankering something to eat. I was sure surprised when I found out how loaded their vegan potato was!!! First, the potato isn’t just baked, it’s also, what seems to be, flash fried which gives the skin this crispy texture. Absolutely amazing. The added topping are so wild together, but compliment each other well. I can see how this little potato ship has lasted so long.


Points +215

18 May 2021

Rustic Vegan Potato

Rustic vegan potato was excellent. All kinds of veggies and even a mango on top. Will be back to order again

Pros: Potential to make a lot of menu items vegan, Friendly staff

Cons: No parking


Points +366

09 Jan 2021

Rustic vegan!

The rustic vegan was full of flavor and filling! Liked that it’s fully vegan with no substitutions or removals. First time here and wasn’t expecting much but was pleasantly surprised! Will be back.

Pros: Flavorful, Friendly and fast service

Cons: Not many options


Points +62

29 Dec 2020

Yummy Vegan Options

Wonderful find on our trip to Annapolis over Christmas Vacation with indoor seating! Vegan options and accommodations were available!

Pros: Great friendly place close to the square, Willing to make accommodations to menu items, Vegan Specific Menu Items

Cons: No child changing station in women’s bathroom


Points +108

Non Veg
19 Jul 2020

Delicious inventive potatoes

I got the vegetarian combo as they mentioned it was the most frequently purchased one. It had so many different vegetables in addition to cheddar cheese and sour cream and two different types of beans. They asked if I wanted it with garlic butter and hot sauce and I replied yes. They are big and filling and delicious. I work in the area and I will definitely be returning

Pros: Good price for the size


Points +180

03 Jul 2020

Amazing! Impeccable service, delicious food

I got the south of the border with no butter or cheese. It is SO GOOD. Delicious food! Service was so good. Cashier was kind. I'm so sad we have nothing like this in Ohio

Pros: Lots of veggie options.

Cons: Very few vegan options(but can be made vegan)


Points +267

20 Feb 2020


Finally able to visit! Hard to find parking, but worth the walk!!
Ordered the Rustic Vegan and South of the Valley (without butter). So good!! I am so full!

Pros: Willing to change items, Delicious

Cons: Parking


Points +1341

10 Jan 2020

Loving that Rustic Vegan

Stopped in for an afternoon snack and ordered the Rustic Vegan, their only 100 % vegan option. It was delicious, the abundant serving of vegetables on top of the potato were cooked just right. They do not have a vegan cheese available, but are working on potentially adding that option. They use olive oil instead of cow butter.

Pros: One really bomb vegan option, Knowledgeable staff

Cons: Only the one vegan option really


Points +49

17 May 2019

Quick and tasty

I was surprised that a place like this exists. I got the vegan potato and it was good. It didn't completely feel like a cohesive dish, like there was everything thrown on but not an overall flavor. I think it needed balsamic or something to tie it together. The potato was perfect though.
I'm definitely going to stop by again with my fiance so he can try it. I'm going to try one of their other veggie potatoes with no cheese and hopefully update to 4 stars if it's good. Willing to give it a second taste.


Points +33

14 Jul 2018

Great restaurant!

Over half the menu is vegetarian and the vegetarian items are listed on their own board.
The staff will let you try some of the toppings if you're undecided.
Great location (directly across from the Statehouse) with some outside seating.

Pros: Many vegetarian options., Delicious!

Cons: None

This page has been viewed 4182 times.