Report a review
- 5
- Best option for Ice Cream around
Of all the different places to get ice cream in the Watkins Glen/Ithaca area, this is your best option. Purity in Ithaca has Chicago Soy Ice Cream and the other place down the street from here has the soft serve, both of which are ok. Colonial is homemade. It's a little less creamy but still just as good as typical vegan ice cream. They use coconut and almost milks to make their ice cream. I had the chocolate oreo, my fiance had mint chocolate chip. We both loved it. There is typically live music and places to sit outside or inside. Your best bet is to grab dinner at Wildflower, try a beer from Crooked Rooster (attached with Wildflower) and then walk over to Colonial for some ice cream.