Vegan creamery and deli offering a variety of plant-based cheeses and sauces as well as savory foods to-go like pizza, 'meatball' subs, sandwiches, bowls, lasagna, pesto and garlic rolls. May order online in advance for pickup. Accepts orders for custom cakes as well. Est. 2017 at Stepstone Hill Rd and moved here in 2019. Has one other location on Water St. Open Wed-Fri 12:00pm-5:00pm, Sat-Sun 11:00am-5:00pm.
-
645 Boston Post Rd, Guilford, Connecticut, USA, 06437
-
Loading...
-
-
Last update on 21 Aug 2021 by ThreeGirlsVegan
Update business info -
Added by ThreeGirlsVegan on 29 May 2017
-
-
86 Reviews
First Review by veganri
Sassafrass
Points +104
Delicious options - Edit
Much of the food here was incredible! We were in town for a concert and splurged on a little of everything! The Caesar salad, sausage pesto fried dough, and chicken and eggplant parm were incredible. Squash blossom apizza was top notch! Desserts were incredible too. We brought home the crab cakes and aged cheese wheels were disappointing - they lacked flavor and were very expensive, so that was even more disgusting that they weren’t very good.
Read morePros: Mostly delicious , Good selection
Cons: Some items lacked flavor , Expensive , Not many healthy options
Guest
pinkerbelle317
Points +89
Love at first bite - Edit
Amazing, all vegan place with sandwiches, pizzas, lasagna, crab cakes, and much more! Also ice cream, brownies, cookies, and other desserts. I've been coming to this place for a few years now, and I'm never disappointed!
Read morePros: Delicious, Good quality
Cons: Expensive, No bathroom
Guest
WLWOLFE
Points +125
Worth taking a drive - Edit
Good portion size , yummy but a bit pricey .
Read morePros: Lavender cookie sample , Friendly service , Small dining in area but still cozy
Guest
vegantchr
Points +66
Must try - Edit
Delicious food! Great variety, super nice and helpful staff, good sized food portions. Bakery items are delicious as well. Pie slices are small but cookie size is big.
Read morePros: Very friendly staff, Tasty food and baked goods
Cons: Took a little long for our food to come out.
Guest
sophiamihalek
Points +147
Great frozen and dine in options - Edit
They had a great variety. They have a huge bakery and large restaurant menu, with frozen entrees available to buy as well. The frozen lasagna was okay and the fresh vegan cheese was delightful. I’d love to try more of their menu
Read morePros: Frozen options, Bakery, Fresh cheese
Guest
devon_lee
Points +128
was okay - Edit
i have been wanting to try this place for years, i have always heard such great things and im sad to report i was SO disappointed. my girlfriend and i came for lunch and i had the buffalo chicken sandwich with chips, i also grabbed some mac and cheese balls and tiramisu to bring back home for later. the chicken itself had no flavor to it and was like eating a sponge, the vinegary buffalo sauce that smothered it was the only flavor noted. the mac and cheese bites we brought home and heated later were not bad but honestly i have had much better and would not buy again, the coconut bacon they put on top was simply not for me and i had to pick off. lastly the tiramisu was the only food i can say i liked from there but then again how can dessert go wrong?
Read morePros: 3 stars because everything is vegan
Cons: minimal indoor seating
Guest
Vindicated-Vegan
Points +68
Fantastic options, but beware of dining in - Edit
I cannot say enough good things about the quality and variety of the vegan entrées and baked goods here.  However, one should be aware that the space is very small if choosing to dine in. Inside, there are two tables with four seats, positioned too closely together to pull the chairs back and crowded between the entrance and display cases. It is a counter order establishment, and people waiting to place their orders, or for their orders to be completed, crowded around the one open side of the tables. There also were two small (2 person) cocktail tables outside that had people seated in them and crowded around them. In short, I found it to be an unpleasant dining in experience. Added to that, it must’ve been the lunchtime rush when I was there. It took nearly half an hour for our food to be ready. They did not seem to give any priority for the people who had ordered to dine in versus all the takeout orders.  if I were in the area again, I would call ahead to order hot food and then only counter order things that are packaged already or baked goods. I hope they grow the business to a point where they can get a sit down restaurant space that is more conducive to a positive dining experience.
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2023-10-23
Pros: Great variety, Lots of delicious baked goods
Cons: Very small and crowded Space for dining in.
Guest
JeffLawrence
Points +142
Solid Vegan Fare - Edit
We stopped down for some take out today at thier new location. The staff was seriously in the weeds with all the customers, and the chaos of being in a new location.
Read moreWe had the vegan meatball subs. They were huge, and the sauce was excellent, if a little light on the application. The meatballs were pretty solid, but sweet for my tastes. Your mileage may vary. We also added some wings -- the habanero which was pretty potent, and the buffalo, which was good and not overpowering.
The tub of vegan smoked maple bacon was a standout.
We also picked up frozen vegan ribs and pastrami. I'll edit this review once we try them.
Edit: We had the ribs last night. They were a pretty standard seitan make, and definitely tasted as such. The BBQ sauce was a sweet one. Like with the meatballs, not to my tastes, but that's a me thing. YMMV. The density was nice in the ribs -- not spongy like some seitan is.
Updated from previous review on 2023-10-02
Guest
LPveg
Points +447
So good - Edit
Everything I've tried from here has been fantastic. The lasagna and eggplant rollatini remind me of the comfort food i grew up with. The fried "clams" are addictive!
Read moreGuest
chels2ocean
Points +1008
Mouthwatering menu - Edit
Everything here looks and sounds so good! I ended up trying the belissimo sandwich and it was fantastic. Hope to stop here again
Read moreGuest
TaliaCohen
Points +18
Best pizza ever! - Edit
I’m not usually one to leave reviews, but after eating here I needed to! My friend and I had the Mac n cheese pepperoni pizza and it was the best pizza I have ever had. It was incredibly flavorful and creamy — and vegan!! I will definitely make the trip again for that pizza and looking forward to trying the rest of the menu. Thanks the lovely woman at the counter for the recommendation :)
Read moreGuest
brandeexv
Points +510
Phenomenal - Edit
Everything I tried here was soooo good! The proportions are also big! They have unique things on the menu that can be hard to find at other vegan spots. The vegan Italian food here is so impressive . Also the waitress gave out free garlic knots😊
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2023-07-03
Guest
Herbievore310
Points +261
Everything is amazing! - Edit
I LIVE for the specials but the classics are amazing too. The best vegan food ever I am so beyond grateful they are in CT!!!! BBQ pizza will always be a top 3!!
Read morePros: Always clean!, Super friendly staff!, SO MANY OPTIONS !!!!!
Cons: Not a lot of place to sit
Guest
Debweidinger223
Points +28
Amazing! - Edit
Everything we tried during our two visits was amazing! I wish the owner would open one in NJ!
Read morePros: Organic , Fast but made to order, Friendly
Guest
TechDogZen
Points +37
Must go to place! - Edit
First timers and while I am more plant based, this is newer to my husband. G
Read moreFood is Fabulous! We will be back for more
Guest
ToyaFroman
Points +77
First visit - Edit
Everything was GREAT!! My daughter said it was the best Caesar salad she’s had and I really wish I’d brought home some of the buttermilk dressing! Amazing!!!
Read morePros: All Vegan, Taste, Variety
Cons: Wish it was closer to my house. Lol
Guest
DeeDreamsInColors
Points +75
Scalloped Potatoes - Edit
These are creamy and dreamy!! Best I’ve ever had! Highly recommend!
Read morePros: All vegan menu!, Friendly staff, Available individual portions and for catering
Guest
KileyOBrien
Points +358
Delicious - Edit
I love the garlic knots! The chicken looks real and is delicious!!
Read morePros: All vegan options, Garlic knots are amazing , So good
Guest
AllisonGuarino
Points +26
Good Food Lousy Customer service - Edit
I've supported Three Girls Vegan Creamery business from the start when they did a Pop up at Compassionfest, through their first location and at both of the newer locations. I've spent a few thousands on their food. They don't like to hear about unhappy customers when they mess up an order. Believe me, it has happened quite a few times. Although I did let them know about the mistakes, it didn't deter me from continuing to order from them.
Read moreSome of the issues were : Ordered a Broccoli and Cheese Soup served in a Bread Bowl. They ran out of Bread Bowl but didn't tell me ( that was the only reason I was ordering it). Nor was I given a credit for not receiving the bread bowl.
Ordered a Mozzarella en Carrozza Sandwich to heat at home.The picture showed a container of sauce to dip it in.
Well, no sauce was given. When I questioned it, they said that they only give sauce if you order it to be heated. I didn't have sauce at home, so I had an added cost to buy some.
I ordered an Eggplant Sandwich on Ciabatta Bread, but they made it on a Fried Dough. These problems were brought to their attention. Also, recently I went to the Downtown location and purchased some baked goods. I paid in cash. It came out to exactly $25. I did message them to question how it could be an exact amount, no taxes, etc. Their response was that they don't have any change in the cash drawer, so they round down in the customers favor. What about all the tax revenue the State is losing out on?
One of my recent orders, I was sent via Door Dash, the wrong soup. They were out of stock on what I ordered. Without my consent, they gave me an entirely different one. When I called to question this, they first said to take it up with DoorDash. Why should I fault the delivery when it was Three Girls that made the decision to give me a different food item. After going back and forth with this via phone calls and emails, they finally agreed that I could come by and pick up another soup. Mind you, it was over $17. for the White Bean Soup that I originally ordered. I kept on checking their website, but that particular Soup had not been back on the menu, so I waited a while longer. It was almost a month, and it still wasn't featured. I decided to call again and ask for a $17 credit so I could get something else. The other soups they were making did not appeal to me. I ended up on the phone with one of the owners. She started out pretty nasty, saying that they gave me enough time to get another soup.
Pros: Vegan
Cons: Bad Attitude from owners when mistakes happen, Rude people , Expensive
Guest
vegonugs
Points +1654
amazing!! - Edit
all the food was fast and amazing! a lot of stuff is fried , but it was certainly a treat in a gorgeous place😄since going vegan, i have always craved my nonnas cutlet grinders…. oh boy did this place bring back memories!!
Read moreGuest
Staceghost
Points +150
Delicious! - Edit
Our family always stops and gets supplies here when we come to visit. They always get us the cannoli dip, which is ridiculously good!
Read moreThis time we tried the fresh mozzarella balls, ricotta, pepper jack, and block mozzarella. Everything was fabulous but especially the mozzarella balls!
Can’t wait to visit them again and try more :)
Pros: Great options , Order ahead
Guest
mkindness
Points +132
Friendly, with amazing food! - Edit
I found this gem by searching on Happy Cow while I was in the area. I’m so glad I did! When I went in, the owner greeted me enthusiastically, asking if it was my first time there. She was so pleased to hear that I had just discovered them, and went to get me a sample of their lasagna, which was delicious. I ended up ordering the Chicken Parm sandwich, made with house-made seitan. Check out the picture to see what a monster that sandwich was.
Read moreMy only regret is that I didn’t buy a bunch of stuff from their prepared foods case to take home with me. I live two hours away and am considering a trip just to stock up!
Updated from previous review on 2022-10-23
Guest
KittenxWitch
Points +52
Absolutely delicious! A must visit! All vegan, all yummy! Friendly staff! - Edit
We loved everything! We came all the way from Florida to finally try their food, and it was worth it! Wish they weren’t so far from us. Everyone that worked there was super friendly and even gave us a treat for our honeymoon! So many delicious choices, from entrees, to desserts, Three Girls Vegan is a must visit!
Read morePros: All vegan, Friendly staff, Food is delicious!
Guest
soyboy3
Points +423
absolutely the best ever - Edit
there is not one bad thing on the menu here.
Read morePros: totally vegan, unbelievably good
Cons: far from where i live lol
AllisonGuarino
Until they mess up your order and blame you for their mistakes
Read moreGuest
iloveveganicecream
Points +943
Delicious vegan Italian food - Edit
Yum!!!! The calzones, fried chick’n, eggplant rollatini, and bellisimo sandwich are all great.
Read morePros: It’s all so good
Cons: Weird hours
Guest
pnichols31
Points +105
Popular for a reason! - Edit
It is no wonder this is such a popular choice (I stopped counting how many people picked up orders, ordered to-go, etc. while I was here)! The taste is soooo good, options are plentiful, and there is plenty of it!
Read moreI've been trying to get here (live 180 miles away) for months, and am NOT disappointed!!
Now, if only I can find some room for brownies or cannolis!
Pros: Delicious!, Large portions., Traditional flavors
Guest
Naudin
Points +46
Hell yes - Edit
Fully vegan Italian-American junk food, fantastic!
Read morePros: Amazing food, Great desserts
Cons: Tiny bit expensive
Guest
For Members
Why was my review removed? Guidelines for writing a review View our privacy policyFor Business Owners
Claim this business
See inaccurate information? Submit an update here Link to this page from your site See an unfair review? View full terms & conditionsThis page has been viewed 15733 times.