• The Pizza Press

  • (5)
    14
    Loading...
  • White Veg-options
Lacto
Pizza
Italian
Beer/Wine
Take-out
Non-veg

Serves meat, vegan options available. Build-your-own pizza restaurant offering many pizza combinations with vegetables. Can get vegan cheese (for a charge). Has Virgil’s brand cream or root beer. Employees change gloves to prevent cross contamination. Open Mon-Wed 11:00am-8:00pm, Thu 11:00am-8:30pm, Fri-Sat 11:00am-9:30pm, Sun 11:00am-8:00pm.


5 Reviews

First Review by JTA

JTA

Points +645

Vegan
10 May 2021

Great pizza!

Lots of vegan options. Tell them you have an allergy and they will use fresh stuff.

eylowe

Points +93

Vegan
15 Aug 2025

Tbh—Just a Weird Experience Overall

I'm not really sure where to begin. Overall, the pizza isn't bad. I would eat it again. The experience was a bit more off putting, though.

When I ordered, the person handled my pizza with the same gloves I had seen them grab chicken wings with, before I had a chance to say anything. That's on me, I was sort of disoriented as I was trying to figure out how things worked. I requested vegan cheese and they were careful to not touch the cheese with their gloves... until they decided to redistribute it around the pie 😅 At this point, the cross-contamination had already happened so I just told myself not to think about it.

I paid and waited for my buzzer to go off.

When I went up to retrieve my pizza I heard the person who took it out of the oven tell the cashier "it's vegan cheese." The cashier said, "Oh, I forgot to charge you, is it okay if you pay for it now?" I was pretty caught off guard, mostly because I didn't have my wallet on me. As I was frantically trying to find the words to say I'd have to come right back, I felt my phone and was able to pay that way. I've never been asked to "retroactively" pay for an add-on before. I don't mind so much, but it was a bit awkward.

That interaction sort of left a bad taste in my mouth, figuratively. I understand there being an up-charge for alternative products, and was aware there would be from other reviewers. What I didn't expect was for the cheese to cost $3.76 after tax (see Apple Pay transaction). The counter with the options listed had said "vegan cheese $2." I later noticed a screen which indicated vegan cheese was $3.50. I guess they haven't updated all of the pieces. Anyways, at the end of the day it's only $3.50, and only $1.50 more than I anticipated spending. It just sort of felt off to me. Just a really odd experience, overall.

I'm not entirely sure I'll return. The pizza was tasty enough, but I left with reservations over the service. I think this is a place I'd go to if I were desperate—just not overly eager to go again.

Oh, and they didn't have any vegan sausage or pepperoni.😢

Cons: Poor communication, Cross-contamination , Out of plant-based "meat"

OperationChowhound

Points +11296

Vegan
16 Feb 2023

ImPressive

I ordered a pizza with red sauce, roasted garlic, vegan cheese, crimini mushrooms, and vegan sausage. The vegan sausage wasn't listed, but the employee suggested it since I chose vegan cheese. The thin-crust pizza was better than I expected, especially since it was ready so quickly. It's pretty big for one person, but too small for two people. I thought the TVs were distracting, but others might enjoy the entertainment.

Pros: customer service

Cons: upcharge for vegan cheese

kaitlyns331

Points +167

Vegan
17 Aug 2022

Good Pizza

A build your own pizza place with lots of toppings to choose from. For vegan alternatives, they had Daiya mozzarella cheese, Gardein sausage, and a vegan pepperoni (that they were out of when I was there). The Daiya cheese had a $2.50 up charge but there was no extra cost for the sausage. They had many vegan friendly toppings to choose from and, in addition to the cheese and sausage, I got roasted garlic, caramelized onions, red sauce, jalapeños, red onions, and cherry tomatoes. My total came out to $18.27, which was kind of expensive for a pizza I could easily eat by myself.

Pros: Good vegan options, Clean, Friendly staff

Cons: A bit pricey

Jadediana

Points +3023

Vegan
18 May 2022

Vegan Cheese & Sausage!

One of the very few places where you can find both vegan cheese and sausage on this island. Love that you don’t have to pay per extra topping. Inside has a great beer selection.




This page has been viewed 0 times.