• Secret Sandwich Society

  • (6)
    8
    Loading...
  • Veg Options Veg Options
Lacto
Ovo
American
Fast food
Take-out
Non-veg

Serves meat, vegan options available. Casual restaurant with vegan choices. Menu includes fries with various vegan-labeled sauces, hummus platter, cauliflower buddha bowl, greek-style salad, vegan fried eggplant sandwich, grilled vegetable sandwich, Beyond burger with vegan cheese and vegan chocolate chip cookie. Open Mon-Sun 11:00am-9:00pm.


6 Reviews

First Review by CPIN

gogreenwithannagene

Points +581

Vegan
28 Jul 2026

Secret Sandwich Society

I didn’t have a great experience here unfortunately. There is only one sandwich that can be made vegan, and it’s a breaded eggplant one, which sounds amazing, and I was really excited when I saw the “vegan on request” icon next to it. When I ordered, however, the girl at the register didn’t seem to understand the vegan option. I explained it would have to be no cheese and no mayo, but when she entered it in, she only put “no mayo,” so I reiterated to her that it should also be “no cheese,” and I think she only messed it up further from there because I was served a sandwich with BOTH cheese and mayo, and by the time I realized, I was already too far on the road to turn around and get another one made (we got takeout and waited like 40 mins). I think the staff should be better educated on what the vegan option means if they are going to offer it to customers on the menu!

Updated from previous review on 2026-07-28

CaraMc

Points +117

Vegetarian
19 Jun 2026

Delicious salads and vegan options

Very flavorful big salad with delicious cashews, greens, and onions. You could leave the cheese out on several things. They also have beyond burgers with vegan cheese.

Pros: Thanks Good varied menu with several vegan options, Nice friendly service

Cons: It was busy and popular so we sat at the bar

minthin

Points +1134

Vegan
10 Aug 2025

Trouble with vegan, but good

The best part of this place is its name. The food was good, but they had an $3.50 upcharge to sub a beyond patty. The actual burger itself was really good...it was a handmade patty and the mayo was vegan. But it was served with a gf bun bc the regular buns are not vegan and that was... interesting. It honestly wasn't bad but it was an adjustment.

Our server Rebecca was really nice and attentive, and the ambiance was great. I hope this place gets it together and finds a vegan bun.

NIBsmf

Points +1446

Vegan
22 Jun 2025

Tasty

I got the Fillmore eggplant sandwich (replacing regular cheese with vegan cheese makes it vegan, I was told by staff). Aside from peppers on it that were too spicy for my liking, I liked it a lot! My partner liked his Beyond burger a lot. Our only complaint was a long wait, as it took about 45 minutes from ordering to getting our food. We sat at the bar to be able to order immediately, otherwise we would have also had to wait for a table (we went on a Sunday at lunch).

Pros: Tasty, Options mostly labeled , Okay prices

Cons: Few vegan options , Busy and long wait

AndiPandi

Points +190

Vegan
01 Jan 2025

Cookies!!

The vegan chocolate chip cookies are delicious!

Pros: Vegan cookies, Locally owned , Friendly

Cons: Not many vegan options

CPIN

Points +36

Vegan
13 Oct 2024

Beyond burger, vegan cheese and mayo. Vegan/gf chocolate chip cookies for dessert. Nice!

We always love more options, but there’s commitment to including vegans and making them feel comfortable here. Nice!

Pros: Chocolate , Chip, Cookies. 




This page has been viewed 1650 times.