Vegan
American
Pizza
Italian
Fast food
Delivery
Take-out

Vegan pizza by the slice joint in partnership with Philly company Blackbird Pizzeria. Also offers whole pies. Toppings include seitan pepperoni, almond ricotta, caramelized onions, and more. Est. Jun 2016. Fomerly Champs Junior, same owners. Reported closed September 2023.


Venue map for Screamer's Pizzeria - Greenpoint
© OpenStreetMap contributors

182 Reviews

First Review by RichBeBe

Meepz

Points +154

Vegan
28 May 2018

Best Vegan Pizza

Hands down best vegan pizza we’ve ever tried, it felt great to get nyc style pizza that was also vegan.

KathrynHaro

Points +42

Vegan
23 May 2018

Best pizza ever

Seriously the best pizza ever, even my non-vegan friends think so. Tons of different vegan pizzas to choose from and I’ve loved every kind I’ve had. The only downside is that the place is super small and fills up quickly. But the pizza is worth it!

Marie-Eve

Points +29

Vegan
23 May 2018

Best vegan pizza ever!

Worth the detour. It's the best pizza I've eaten.

The place is pitiful. It's extremely small, dirty and staff not too friendly.

A chance that the pizza is good !!

Pros: The amazing taste

Cons: Tiny place, Dirty, Staff not friendly

westchestervegan

Points +1133

Vegan
17 May 2018

Buffalo Cauliflower Pizza is a Must!!!

Although the space is not large, it’s just right for a pizza by the slice or carry out. The staff was not the friendliest but the pizza itself was delicious. It’s right next door to Van Leeuwen’s so you can grab a vegan ice cream right after.

Pros: Creative toppings, A lot of options

Cons: Parking can be challenging

sweetdaddygotu

Points +360

Vegan
26 Apr 2018

exceptionally good pizza

Not a lot of space! Pizza might not look as fresh as it actually is! But the taste is amazing!

Pros: wonderful staff! great pizza!

Cons: limited sitting area!

SamanthaAliseMaizer

Points +26

Vegan
30 Mar 2018

yummm

Tried three of there pizzas. All of them were so good!!!

Tabgreenvegan

Points +1031

Vegan
28 Mar 2018

Best Vegan Pizza Ever!!!

I want to move to Brooklyn eat here every day!!!! Loved the pizza cannoli!! Will be back whenever I visit NY!

Ceecalloway

Points +16

Vegan
16 Mar 2018

yummy!

Excellent atmosphere. Small and cozy, Meant for takeout. Slices are so delicious I can't wait to go back for my second time. Wish I could've taken home a pie!

Pros: good pizza, I don't have to think about missing a

Cons: far commute but I'll manage. the pizza is worth it

janitajasmin

Points +172

Vegan
13 Mar 2018

Good pizza!

The pizza is really tasty! And the staff was friendly. But, the music is horrible lol It was SO LOUD too! And I wanted to eat in... The music was just too loud and it was heavy metal which I don’t really enjoy. Other than that, pizza was good!

svetlabryzgalow

Points +29

Vegan
18 Feb 2018

GOOD VEGAN PIZZA

The Pizza is very good and tasty but the staff is very distracted. they weren't wearing gloves while putting on topics on the pizza. Ewww
Could be more cleaner and more organized!

Cons: dirty , unfocused stuff

murraydos

Points +34

Vegan
15 Feb 2018

found it

Completely vegan pizzeria that's make great pizza. So Manny different pizzas to choose from. About 6 different pizzas sold by the slice . Definitely stop by if your in the area

Pros: 100% vegan like 20 pizzas to choose from . friendl

Cons: not many tables

theevetree

Points +158

Vegan
13 Jan 2018

thought i was being had

we ordered their margherita & their slice of the day barbecue chicken made with jackfruit. i hate vegan pizza because they use daiya cheese which is gross & makes my stomach hurt. screamer's however has found the real deal. i was worried for a moment that it actually was cheese! the ooey gooey melty-ness & the beautiful pools of grease that appears when you fold the slice in your hands...pure heaven. this is the best vegan pizza i've had. when people tell me they won't go vegan cuz they'll miss pizza too much, i'll send them here!!

Pros: tastes like real cheese, great place, great staff, lots of options

Cons: not in queens

fruitiJulie

Points +3252

Vegan
31 Dec 2017

So Good! five stars

This was a great find! Vegan pizza with lots of variety of toppings and vegan proteins. Not Many tables to eat, fills up quickly. The menu has around 20 pre-designed vegan pizzas, calzones, cannoli, drinks and also pre-made slices you can get

US Kiwi

Points +132

Vegan
24 Dec 2017

Thee Vegan pizza we have been looking for!

We have been searching for a good vegan pizza since becoming vegan and by George we found it! They use Violife cheese (NOT Diaya!) and it is amazing. My personal fav was the Buffalo but the Cheese, Screamer, and Tofu Scramble and sausage were all amazing!

SendNooch

Points +264

Vegan
17 Dec 2017

Yummy Vegan New York City Style Pizza

I love this place, I would eat regularly here if I lived closer. The pizza here is delicious. Now, I wouldn't say that their dairy-free pizza tastes exactly as how I remember dairy pizza tasting, but it's a fantastic substitute. When I ate here, I got a regular slice and white pizza - so YUMMY!!! I can't wait to go back again. Additionally, may I include that the staff is friendly, the restaurant is decorated pretty nice, and the town surrounding the restaurant is so cool! I do wish they had a larger selection though, when it comes to buying by the slice, they only have about 6 pies to choose from and I know that New York City pizzerias usually have a much larger selection. Also, slices are a bit on the expensive side. Regardless though, I do recommend checking this place out!

Pros: They Use a Variety of Vegan Cheeses, Taste Great, Cool Enviroment

Cons: Expensive

ERodTM

Points +66

Vegan
04 Dec 2017

Vegan Pizza By The Slice!

Drove here from deep Queens. I’m a regular slice kind of person, and I absolutely loved it. I could have eaten a whole pie on my own. Will be coming back.

Pros: Delicious

Cons: Small, only about 10 seats if you squeeze in.

AshleyMarguerite

Points +39

Vegan
24 Nov 2017

the best!

Best vegan pizza ever! The spicy pesto with cherry tomato is awesome, as is the buffalo 🤤

Kittybiscuit

Points +7703

Vegan
01 Nov 2017

Great pizza, not very helpful staff

We came here specifically to try the pizza before a theatre show. We asked if we had to buy by the slice. There was nothing on the display cabinet to indicate what each pizza was. That would have been helpful. The woman serving just said “yes.” She didn’t do anything remotely helpful and I wished I hadn’t have tipped her. I think she just couldn’t be bothered being there. The pizza was nice but I have no idea which slices we ate!

Cons: person who served us

Yasminesan

Points +1912

Vegan
28 Oct 2017

Fantastic pizza, less than friendly staff

The pizza here is worth going to Brooklyn alone (though of course it's a great place in itself). It was mind blowingly-good. My omni sister said it was better than the regular pizza slices she got. I got two slices and sadly saw them putting out an artichoke flavour as I left - it looked awesome! I also tried the doughballs which were okay, but nothing mind-blowing

The only really disappointing thing was the girl working there - she was actively rude. The only time service was so bad in the city I didn't want to tip. She was just unfriendly and aggressive for no reason, which kind of put down the experience as we travelled for an hour to get there just for the pizza, and it was getting down to my last dollars before I left, so I genuinely had hyped it up a lot in my mind. The pizza at least made it worth it.

Pros: Pizza!, Price

Cons: Staff, Location is not convenient for non-locals

Metin

Points +119

Vegan
22 Oct 2017

Perfect pizza

I had one visit and ended up going there several times during my short stay in NY. Great to be able to buy pizza by the slice and eat your way throigh the menu in this manner!

KerryElise

Points +378

Vegan
16 Oct 2017

best vegan pizza!!

On my trip to New York I went directly from the airport to Screamer’s. The buffalo cauliflower was my favorite. My husband really enjoyed the sausage mushroom. We got 4 slices and they were all really good. I’m usually not the biggest fan of vegan cheese, but they really made it work for the pizza.

Pros: delicious , fast

Cons: small space , limited seating

Seiashun

Points +424

Vegan
14 Oct 2017

All vegan pizza!

We tasted several different slices when we visited, and they were all pretty good. The crust is thin and crispy, their almond ricotta is great. I didn't really like the pepperoni (but I don't like vegan sausage in general, so I might be biased), but I would definitely recommend the "screamer" and their almond ricotta one.

Updated from previous review on 2017-10-14

Pros: Great selection, Great almond ricotta

Cons: Very small place, Pizza was a tad bit too oily

NaomiSommer

Points +30

Vegan
18 Sep 2017

Slightly disappointing

I heard so many great reviews and had very high expectations, and loved the idea of an all vegan pizza joint. I had a slice of the pepperoni - unfortunately, this is where things went downhill. While the crust and sauce were pretty average, the cheese was about identical to any other vegan cheese I could by at a health foods store and make at home with the same result - the cheese was gloopy and sticks to the roof of your mouth - at least the regular mozzarella. Perhaps the other pizzas that involved more toppings, or the almond ricotta - would have been a better choice. The pepperoni was pretty bland, greasy and peppery, not to my liking.
I took a couple bites and quickly realized I'm not a fan at all. I walked up to the cashier to see if I could get something else instead, and she said I'd have to pay again, and that the order is not refundable. I personally would have appreciated a little more accommodation, but to each their own. Just putting it out there.
This place is still worth the visit if you're in Brooklyn, but if you come, lower your expectations.

Pros: cheap, all vegan, verity

Cons: average taste, gloopy cheese, customer service

tofuguts

Points +54

Vegan
18 Sep 2017

I wish this place was closer to where I was staying

Came here with a meat eating friend who lives in NYC.
We were both super impressed with the slice and the price... The pepperoni they used was fantastic!

Wish I was staying closer!

wanderlustarcher

Points +98

Vegan
08 Jul 2017

FREAK YEAH ! I SCREAM EVERYTIME I HAVE YOUR PIZZA!

Just discovered this place about a month ago & had my first vegan slice of pizza ever. I also never liked real pepperonis so thanks for bringing me your own rendition of pepperonis cause now I love em. Lol. Well the vegan kind that is. But you guys are superb. Great music. Great pizza. & the whole pizzeria vibe is just what us vegans needed. Being open so late is just the icing on the cake. Just love it. There's nothing better than a vegan pizza shop next to a ice cream shop with vegan flavors. You guys just set the mood. Thank you.

p_ippa

Points +102

Vegan
07 Jul 2017

You need this pizza

Just go, you won't be disappointed.

770veg

Points +3351

Vegan
07 Jul 2017

radness madness

Dropped in after a dope show in Williamsburg. Got there 10 minutes before closing. Had a pepperoni slice and some garlic knots. Was delightful and the folks were great. Can't wait to try it out when they have a full menu. Za for life!!




This page has been viewed 24880 times.