Vegan
American
Pizza
Italian
Fast food
Delivery
Take-out

Vegan pizza by the slice joint in partnership with Philly company Blackbird Pizzeria. Also offers whole pies. Toppings include seitan pepperoni, almond ricotta, caramelized onions, and more. Est. Jun 2016. Fomerly Champs Junior, same owners. Reported closed September 2023.


Venue map for Screamer's Pizzeria - Greenpoint
© OpenStreetMap contributors

182 Reviews

First Review by RichBeBe

blua

Points +97

Vegan
23 Jul 2023

Good pizza, but could be better

We ordered our food via Uber Eats, so it was not fresh out of the oven, but even taking that into account I think the pizzas could have been better. The ones I had (meathead and cheeseburger) needed more cheese and lacked a bit in flavor, except for the cumin (from one of the fake meats, I assume), which was too strong for my taste. The pizza was good and it's nice to have a fully vegan pizzeria with such an extensive menu, but in my opinion there's room for improvement. The cheese bread was amazing, though!

Sjjk12

Points +1089

Vegan
05 Jul 2023

Nice vegan pizza in nyc

Great pizza dough, great toppings, my favorites were the Buffalo cauliflower and kale seitan, would return. Please make sure to stop by with intentions for pick-up at this location only because they have limited seating.

*Amending this: I was reflecting on this meal and realized that it was really heavy pizza, so it has a fabulous topping game. If you want the super thin crust like 20th Street (Blackbird’s location in Philly), this isn’t it. I am still looking for a more thin crust pizza option in NYC.

Updated from previous review on 2022-12-30

JustLayuh

Points +574

Vegan
24 Jun 2023

Vegan Za by the Slice 😍

Need I say more? Anywhere that has vegan pizza by the slice is a winner in my book 🤩😍. The pizza is on the thinner size, but they have tons of options.

Pros: Pizza by the slice, Vegan pizza

Cons: Limited seating

Monstersdontcry

Points +120

Vegan
04 Jun 2023

Prefect!

Did a little foodtour and this was one of the stops. Good slice of pizza! Worth the trip

ManuK

Points +50

Vegan
24 May 2023

Easy and delicious.

Just grab a slice and go. No headaches about what's vegan and what's not. Easy and delicious with a wide selection of different pizzas. Prices are also quite good.

Ameisherry

Points +9023

Raw
19 May 2023

Amazing vegan pizza options :)

You can even request for gluten free pizza dough😄super amazing thank you thank you thank you😄

daisy12orange

Points +146

Vegan
16 May 2023

best vegan pizza in New York

easily the best pizza I ate in New York. I came here and had two pieces of pizza, while I was there they played the whole of Illmatic - Nas, which gave a cool vibe. decor is also really cool, I particularly enjoyed the picture of the child getting a pizza baptism. I'd come here again if I'm ever back in Brooklyn.

Updated from previous review on 2023-05-15

IsabelaMonteiro

Points +615

Vegan
08 Apr 2023

NY style and approved

We ordered the Vampire pizza flavour for delivery and we really liked it! It definitely looks better than the pictures and it tastes amazing. Looking forward to tasting the other flavors now.. their menu is large, and all vegan!

KMR607

Points +355

Vegan
01 Apr 2023

Great selection

A bunch of yummy slices options, plus wings!

Pros: Good thin crust, Friendly staff, Decent value

Cons: No bathroom

SAVES

Points +61

Vegan
23 Feb 2023

Love this place!

I work in Manhattan and live in Staten Island, once a month I pick up two pies, literally hop on multiple trains and the Ferry just to bring this back home, for me it’s definitely worth the effort, I’ve had plenty of vegan pizza and few compare to screamers!

Beba112

Points +531

Vegan
17 Feb 2023

So so Vegan Pizza

At first I was excited to try out this vegan only pizzeria. I went with my family and I was able to taste the pepperoni, screamers pizza, and the chickn bacon ranch. Out of all of them I liked the pepperoni best. I was a little underwhelmed and had higher expectations given all the reviews this place has, but I’ve had better vegan pizza at other places. The cheese used is Violife which is creamy and good. The sauce could be better or richer. The crust was not too thick and probably more on the thin side which in my opinion really isn’t NY style pizza (I prefer regular crust not thin).

However, despite my personal taste buds and opinions, my non vegan family members actually enjoyed what they ordered. My dad ended up finishing what I did not like.

Pros: Variety

Cons: Expensive slice pizza, Thin crust

seaweed-dog

Points +20

Vegan
20 Jan 2023

Great pizza joint!

We ate here a while ago when visiting NY but never wrote a review! Great pizza joint with friendly staff. Highly recommend!

Pros: Great pizza, Friendly staff

JasonManias

Points +1367

Vegan
15 Jan 2023

Incredible pizza

Definitely a top 5 pizza place in the country for sure

DanielKavanagh

Points +106

Vegetarian
20 Nov 2022

Best vegan pizza in the US

Situated in a cool area of Brooklyn it was worth the ride from Chelsea. Run don’t walk.

angieblah

Points +267

Vegan
12 Nov 2022

Best vegan pizza

Had to come back after our first visit years ago and it’s just as delicious as I remember😋

Yuna_X

Points +619

Vegan
04 Nov 2022

Amazing pizza

So freaking good!! The mushroom one with white sauce is perfection! Slices are pretty big

Raychel

Points +491

Vegan
30 Oct 2022

Amazing pizza

Amazing pizza, cool atmosphere a must try.

Karenmarieis

Points +58

Vegan
09 Oct 2022

PIZZA OF YOUR VEGAN DREAMS

Run-don’t walk to this delicious pizza place! This location has plenty of vegan pizza BY THE SLICE! If you see a grandma slice (square) BUY IT BC IT THEY ARE FEW AND FAR BETWEEN! Standouts include: The Screamer, Cheese Pizza, and white pizza slice.

Pros: TASTY PIZZA, low wait time, decor

Cons: you can’t automatically materialize there

AnneliesVdV

Points +545

Vegan
08 Sep 2022

Slice me up !

Seriously, best pizza I've had in a long time since going vegan.

This place is a must when you visit NYC in my books and as an added bonus you can stroll around in Greenpoint and hit up some shops in Williamsburg, what more do you need?

Ioana3

Points +621

Vegan
02 Sep 2022

Fantastic pizza

We had the large supreme and it was incredible! The large pizza also easily feeds two hungry vegans

Pros: Great variety, Fun options, Large pizza is huge

leg

Points +406

Vegan
27 Aug 2022

Funky Ambiance, Quick and Friendly Staff, Delicious Food

I didn’t get to choose what food I got—due to the fact that I ordered with the TooGoodToGo, but I was pleasantly surprised with the selection and amount I was given and will be coming back. I got 5 slices (the two of which I tried were highly palatable and are authentic to a New York Slice)

MichaelSquillace

Points +574

Vegan
27 Aug 2022

One of the best pizzas I've had!

One of the best pizzas I've had!

INTJ_mara

Points +449

Vegan
23 Aug 2022

Good pizza

If you like thin crust pizza, you will love this place. To be honest I like Vinnie’s better but I would rather support this 100% vegan place😄

Pros: 100% Vegan.

Cons: It’s always way too salty for my liking.

lisasays73

Points +483

Vegan
23 Aug 2022

Just so good

We were on a "brewery tour" in Brooklyn when we decided to get something to eat and found Screamer's just around the corner. We had two slices and they were both excellent - dough and toppings ... I would love to come back one day and try the rest of the selection!

Pros: Great tasting pizza, Unusual ingredients

martint

Points +7760

Vegan
05 Aug 2022

Same as other comments: Best vegan pizza in NYC

I tried 3 vegan pizza venues during my last trip to NYC and this one was by difference the best for me.

dirtyrotten

Points +352

Vegan
26 Jul 2022

Best vegan slices

I love paulie gees vegan options and Vinnie’s on Bedford held me down until screamers came around.

ToddSing

Points +48

Vegan
17 Jul 2022

Best vegan pizza anywhere

I love this place. I go anytime I can make it work.

Pros: All Vegan pizza, Lots of choices, Best vegan pepperoni I have had




This page has been viewed 24732 times.