• Scarr's Pizza

  • (12)
    59
    Loading...
  • White Veg-options
Lacto
American
Pizza
Italian
Fast food
Beer/Wine
Delivery
Non-veg

Serves meat, vegan options available. Pizzeria with vegan offerings, including pizza slices, customizable whole pies, and vegan Caesar salad. Open Mon-Thu 11:30am-12:00am, Fri-Sat 11:30am-1:00am, Sun 11:30am-11:00pm.


Venue map for Scarr's Pizza
© OpenStreetMap contributors

12 Reviews

First Review by VeganNole

Ad3le

Points +173

Vegan
14 Oct 2024

Nothing special

The highlight was the tomato sauce. Vegan cheese was not great. Was just happy to have an option at the same time as my omni friend.

how_soon_is_then

Points +126

Vegan
25 Aug 2024

nothing special

you can tell that not much thought/resources were put into choosing the vegan cheese for the slices here. it tastes ok, but not worth eating it again

Updated from previous review on 2024-08-25

rtnc68

Points +655

Vegan
16 May 2024

So so

Was so looking forward to this vegan pizza - was bland. But at least they have a vegan option.
Don’t go out of your way for this.

lh0p98

Points +500

Vegan
18 Apr 2024

Great slice options !!

Great place to grab a slice for vegans. Also have vegan garlic knots which are delicious. You can take out or grab a drink and eat your slice at the bar.

Updated from previous review on 2024-04-18

stefandrury

Points +151

Vegan
17 Nov 2023

Vegan slice and full pizza option

Had a takeaway slice here and they offered a vegan thick crust tomato and garlic pizza. The sauce and flavours were really good. There’s also a vegan pizza with vegan cheese on the menu, but when we went that was only for a full pizza, not a takeaway slice.

sazzyom

Points +140

Vegan
30 Sep 2023

Great slice!

Affordable & tasty vegan slices

CactusCooler

Points +375

Vegan
22 Mar 2023

An option

An option but nothing special, no flavor on vegan pizza. At least they added basil after they heated it. Could do something to it…Caesar is vegan and DANK tho

Pros: Caesar good, 1 pizza option for slices - cheese

Cons: Expensive and long line

craigmc

Points +35482

Vegan
07 Jul 2022

Denied

We were in the area and had seen the great reviews so stopped d for a quick lunch.
They had no vegan slices and no interest in making them. Disappointing.

PurpleCurrant

Points +3898

Vegan
27 Mar 2022

Best vegan pizza

Ok so I'm a bit conflicted about this because the place is not even vegetarian, but this was the best vegan pizza I've had in North America. Will definitely be back when in NYC. I don't know what cheese they use but it's just perfect!

drquayle

Points +738

Vegan
02 Oct 2021

Would do 5 stars if I could

Since they serve non veg items, the system doesn’t allow a five star review — only reason for four stars!

This was one of my go to spots when I was vegetarian, since pizza was my favorite food. I was delighted today to realize they have a vegan option. So I went, and I was blown away. The vegan mozzarella is there to complement the other flavors instead of being the main focus, and it works perfectly.

Most claims that “omnivores would go for it” or be fooled are overstatements in my opinion. There are just certain foods that don’t veganize super well, and I’ve long felt pizza is one of them (I prefer to just embrace awesome plant foods instead) — I do eat vegan slices occasionally to satisfy craving or for nostalgia, but it’s not because it’s as good as I remember cheese slices being. This slice though could be the rare exception. It really is amazing.

Nowadays I don’t have as much appetite for things like pizza — I love good plant based foods. But when I do get the craving, I know where I’m going to go 😎

Updated from previous review on 2021-10-02

Pros: Amazing flavor

csailor

Points +877

Vegan
05 Jun 2021

INCREDIBLE vegan pizza

This may be my top spot for vegan pizza in all of nyc. Amazing sauce, crust, & they use NUMU! the basil is a nice touch too. Plus its right down the street from other favorite vegan spots!

VeganNole

Points +223

Vegan
01 Sep 2019

Amazing vegan pizza!

Located in an area with so many amazing vegan options, I decided to stroll into Scarr’s because they offer vegan pizza slices made with NUMU vegan cheese—which is a local NY cheese company and probably one of the best vegan mozzarellas out there, if you haven’t tried it already. It’s locally made and amazing and your omni friends could be fooled. Slices are only $4 and I noticed they charged the same for the regular slices, which is a huge plus! You can also order vegan whole pies and customize those as well as the slices however you want. They also have vegan Caesar salad. I love this place and wish they had locations all over the city!

Pros: Amazing pizza , Don’t up-charge for vegan




This page has been viewed 5991 times.