• Sadie's Ice Cream

  • (12)
    10
    Loading...
  • Ice-cream Ice Cream

Ice cream shop offering one or two dairy-free flavors such as black cherry or butter pecan. Vegan flavors are kept in a different fridge away from the display, so ask for them. Please note that the cones are not vegan. Open Mon-Sun 11:00am-9:00pm.


Venue map for Sadie's Ice Cream
© OpenStreetMap contributors

12 Reviews

First Review by arw22

jesikah-murray

Points +79

Vegan
23 Jul 2024

Only 1 flavor

Only had black cherry flavor but was delicious (they said they rotate through 1 at a time).
All cones have diary so you need to order it in a cup.

Meanderingvegetarians

Points +117

Vegetarian
14 Jul 2024

Vegan Black Cherry

Delicious vegan black cherry ice cream 😍 Hit the spot on a hot day after walking around the island.

Vegan Vagabond

Points +4158

Vegan
06 Jul 2024

The only place on the island for vegan ice cream

In the past, they only had vanilla. I went in today and they had wild cherry and butter pecan. Times are a changing.😄

Update 7/6/24: The only flavor they serve is “Veg-O-Licious Black Cherry.” I see the review below, and maybe I’ve been vegan too long and just can’t remember what real ice cream is like, but this is pretty damn good vegan ice cream, to me. My wife thinks so, also. YMMV. A one scoop cone is $10, but welcome to Mackinac Island, this is how everything is.

Updated from previous review on 2022-08-28

SVathne

Points +457

Vegan
16 Jul 2023

Vegan "icecream" if you can call it icecream..

I love icecream and was excited to see all the good comments, so I had to visit. The parlour was beautiful and in a nice location (next to the Grand Hotel), but they only had one vegan option, "Vegan Black Cherry". I ordered 2 scoops, and they were HUUGE (11dollars)! When it comes to the flavour, it was horrible. It tasted artificial and nothing like icecream. I was not able to eat it and had it throw it away. It's not worth the money..

Updated from previous review on 2023-07-15

Pros: Beautiful parlour

Cons: Horrible taste, Expensive

bicycleben

Points +172

Vegan
18 Jun 2023

Cherry ice cream was insane!

Huge cherry chunks in this oat based ice cream 😋

DeliseAiken

Points +73

Vegan
16 Jun 2023

Only flavor is cherry currently

Be sure to check what flavors are actually vegan, ordered butter pecan but it was not vegan 🥲 cherry was amazing though

AaronWissner

Points +135

Vegan
18 Sep 2022

Amazing Vegan Ice Cream

So very good, wanted to get more immediately, if not for the Calories

Pros: Amazing cherry vegan coconut ice cream, Very good butter pecan vegan ice cream, reasonable prices

Cons: long walk up to the Grand Hotel

nicolevidak

Points +293

Vegan
13 Aug 2021

Just one flavor

All they had was boring vanilla vegan ice cream. I tried it first and it was a good flavor - I could taste the coconut milk with which it's made. I would've loved another option but I am always happy when there's even one flavor!

Cons: Only one vegan option

Vegan Vagabond

28 Aug 2022

Today, they had wild Cherry and butter pecan.

MichelleSapsara

Points +46

Vegan
13 Jul 2021

Pretty good

They only had one flavor when we were there- vanilla. The staff member asked me if I wanted to taste it like three times when I asked about it and told her I wanted it. Since there are no other dairy-free choices, I was pretty sure we were going to get it lol!

gracielizmill

Points +170

Vegan
16 Aug 2020

I scream for ice cream

We made the walk to the grand hotel just to get some vegan ice cream. Well worth it!

Pros: In a separate case , Cones option , Very cute atmosphere

riri444

Points +48

Vegan
13 Aug 2020

Ehhh

The vegan option they had was Coconut Vanilla and it was stored in a separate jug in the back. It tasted very bland

arw22

Points +245

Non Veg
22 Jun 2019

Good non-dairy chocolate

Sadie’s ice cream parlor is in the Grand Hotel. You have to ask for the non-dairy flavors (kept separately). I was a fan of the chocolate, but I found the birthday cake too sweet. Worth checking out for good non-dairy ice cream on the island.




This page has been viewed 3220 times.