Lacto
Ovo
Non-veg

Serves meat, vegan options available. Makes daily single-serving pies, both sweet and savory, plus a soup of the day. Usually 2 or 3 veg/vegan options - check its facebook. Open Wed-Sat 12:00pm-7:00pm, Sun 12:00pm-6:00pm.


Venue map for Proper Pie Co.
© OpenStreetMap contributors

14 Reviews

First Review by AshleyBoutwell

iampureart

Points +434

Vegan
24 Jan 2024

10/10

HIGHLY RECOMMEND. It was absolutely delicious. The flaky crust and filling was so hearty and ugh. Perfection.

juanmendg

Points +25

Vegan
31 Dec 2023

Yum

Got their vegan pie of the day, which was chili and cheese. Very savory. Takeout only, but the park across the street is a good spot to sit.

Pros: Pie

Cons: Not the cheapest but not unreasonable

SandyW.

Points +78

Vegan
04 Nov 2023

Good pies

I had the vegan cheesesteak pie (has vegan cheese inside) and the vegan strawberry rhubarb pie. The cheesesteak pie was very good but kind of sweet and rich. A little too strong for my stomach, couldn't eat it all, but quite tasty. Pie crust was delicious. The strawberry pie was delicious and not overly sweet. Serves up fast as they are premade. No inside dining, but some tables outside. They were full when we visited so we went to the park right across the street which had some benches. Nice place for a quick, yummy bite.

Pros: Delicious pies, 4 vegan dessert pies

Cons: Only one vegan pie option, Outside tables only

smileykylie

Points +344

Vegan
01 Nov 2023

Savory and sweet vegan options!!

Quick and tasty! When we went they had 1 choice of vegan savory pie (vegan cheddar and bean) and many vegan sweet pies. The vegan cheddar and bean pie was very good and quite filling on its own. For the sweet pie I got the vegan pear and cranberry pie (per recommendation from the person taking orders) which I can’t recommend enough! It was the perfect balance between sweet and tart. The menu is clearly labeled and your pie even comes in a little “I’m vegan!” bag, which always makes me feel a bit safer at omni places. When we went there was no indoor seating and the outdoor seating was limited to three tables. I recommend taking your pies to go and having a little picnic at Libby Hill Park!

Updated from previous review on 2023-11-01

Pros: Clearly labeled vegan options, Very quick service , Delicious!!!!

Cons: Limited seating

vegan55

Points +134

Vegan
30 Sep 2023

Solid

Lots of vegan options. Both savory and sweet. Fruit cobbler was decent but I had been prepared for something better. Happy to try again.

LauraVeg31

Points +169

Vegan
24 Sep 2023

Awesome!

Awesome little pie store with very easy online ordering and good prices, so yummy too. I love a good vegan savory pie option

ElissaBVegan

Points +2599

Vegan
24 Apr 2023

Nice vegan pies

We were happy to find tasty vegan options at this very popular pie place, which in April 2023 is only carry-out.

Pros: Clearly labeled vegan pies, Tasty

turtleveg

Points +1645

Vegan
21 Apr 2019

Ahhhmazing!

Thanks to HappyCow I stopped by but honestly wasn’t anticipating being blown away. Was I wrong! So many vegan options and everything was so delicious! The staff was awesome. The crusts, creativity, and variety impressed me. The Meyer lemon blackberry was the favorite. Also appreciated the delicious oat milk cappuccino.

Rgarb003

Points +88

Vegan
14 Aug 2018

Holy happy cow...

I wish I could give this place 5 stars! The vegan pies here are freaking phenomenal!

Pros: Savory and sweet choices, Delicious

GuidedbyVeggies

Points +67

Vegan
01 Jul 2018

Vegan savory pie ; so good!

My partner and I recently stopped in this small, cute & busy spot for some vegan New Zealand style pie. They always have at least one vegan savory pie! When we visited, the option of the day was a chili “cheese” pie, and it was delicious! They make their own vegan cheese in house (cashew-based). We took this little (but filling) hand pie to Maymont Park, and shared it there on a hot, early Spring day. They may only have one vegan option, but it’s definitely worth it! I just wish they had more than one option, because their pies are good.

We did an episode on our experience here (plus tasting the pie at Maymont Park) on our vegan YouTube channel if anyone is interested in seeing it!
➡️ https://youtube.com/channel/UCQ3ffXtIrXm3AkvsqUYRFbg







Updated from previous review on 2018-05-31

Pros: Great for taking out on a vegan picnic!

Cons: wish they had more than one vegan option

Mitchel

Points +292

Vegan
06 Jun 2018

Something for everyone.

They usually have a few vegan flavors of pie. The blueberry pie is great.

Pros: Several vegan flavors.

Cons: Very busy!

JohnGardner

Points +640

Vegan
08 May 2017

Vegan "meat" pies!

The vegan 'steak and cheese' is fantastic (see my photo), I'm so glad it was on the menu the day I was there. They package them to-go in a paper pouch labelled vegan, so if you are grabbing some for vegans and some for non-vegans, you can tell them apart when you get home, nice touch!

Ejl500

Points +49

Mostly Veg
06 May 2017

worth the trip!!!

Vegan 'steak & cheese' pie is worth a separate trip on its own. Other vegan options include sweet pies like strawberry rhubarb and blueberry apple. Yum yum yum!!!

AshleyBoutwell

Points +137

Vegan
02 May 2017

a favorite!

Always has one vegan savory pie, several vegan sweet pies, and the soup is vegan.




This page has been viewed 4397 times.