• Old Town Mexican Cafe

  • (15)
    34
    Loading...
  • White Veg-options
Lacto
Ovo
Beer/Wine
Take-out
Mexican
Breakfast
Non-veg

Serves meat, vegan options available. Casual eatery serving Mexican food. Has a separate vegetarian section of the menu with several vegan items and others that can be made vegan on request. Open Mon-Thu 11:30am-10:30pm, Fri-Sun 11:30am-11:00pm.


Venue map for Old Town Mexican Cafe
© OpenStreetMap contributors

15 Reviews

First Review by Susiesuse

keylimexo

Points +430

Vegan
17 Nov 2024

Improved from my last visit

Very friendly service and I enjoyed the food more than when I went a few years ago. For Mexican food in Key West I prefer tacos at Amigos or the Cafe, or the veggie fajitas at Chico's Cantina or Hard Rock. This place is just OK for the price as other reviewers said.

Pros: Friendly service, Duval Street location

Cons: No parking, A bit pricey

SelahStar

Points +33

Vegetarian
02 Jul 2024

Vegan not Vegan

They fry chips in the same oil as seafood so not truly Vegan nachos etc, did not eat there but appreciate their honesty!

Updated from previous review on 2024-07-02

Pros: Honest about mixing with non vegan

Cons: Vegan not vegan

Worldvegkitchen

Points +1295

Vegetarian
09 May 2024

Decent Mexican food

This is a good veg friendly spot. I ordered the fried avocado tacos which was vegan. The portions are a little small (not your typical big plate Mexican restaurant) and expensive. I was happy with the food, but not happy about being charged $4.50 for the side guacamole which was basically two tablespoon quantity. Think I got 4 chips worth out of that.

Paint910

Points +43

Vegan
15 Mar 2024

Good Vegan Option!

Oh happy day. This was our first meal during our Key West vacay and we arrived during happy hour😄. Excellent house margarita! Everyone should make them like this. We had the guacamole app, veggie fajitas and garden burrito. All were great!

Pros: Vegan options, House margaritas , Cute outdoor seating

tofuscrambles

Points +76

Vegan
14 Jan 2024

Taste Fresh

Cocktails, salsa and food were very refreshing and full of flavor. Sat outside with the chickens. Got the fried avocado tacos and they were so yummy.

Pros: Atmosphere , Location , Fresh ingredients

Julia_DUS

Points +183

Vegan
06 Dec 2023

Very good mexican food

Very nice mexican restaurant in old town of Key West. They offer a lot of vegetarian and vegan options. Food and service was really good, can totally recommend :)

lilmeowmeow

Points +168

Vegan
12 Nov 2023

Good service, disappointing food

I really wanted to like this place still after going vegan, but their vegan options are limited, and the food I've gotten here the last two times I've been here was dry. I'm sure plenty of people can enjoy the food here, it just isn't for me.

jakobwb

12 Nov 2023

harrietsleveen

Points +152

Vegan
23 Oct 2023

Good service and food

Fun location. They know how to veganize and have quite a few options. They did a great job on our meal- we were high maintenance.

Pros: Good location, Good service & value, Good food

JenniferCook

Points +872

Vegan
19 Feb 2023

Great find

Phenomenal fresh food. We had a bean burrito (not on the menu), black bean and avocado tacos, and guacamole. Drool-worthy. Will definitely be back.

Pros: Great outdoor atmosphere , Great vegan options, Really nice people

JenniferGannon

Points +108

Vegan
12 Feb 2023

Bb tacos and bean burrito

Super accommodating fresh & delicious- a great option in a vegan desert like Key West

Pros: Affordable , Fresh , Tasty

Cons: None

chunkyvegan

Points +140

Vegan
09 Jun 2022

Great dinner

We’ve had a hard time finding a good vegan dinner in the keys. But this was delicious. Food was fresh and tasty. Service was excellent. We dined at the bar and the bartender was very knowledgeable and gave us several options. They have a small vegetarian section but they will also make other dishes vegan. We had the black bean and avocado tacos and they made my fiancé a vegan chimichanga which he devoured.

Pros: Lots of options, Fresh and delicious, Excellent happy hour

ToddKing

Points +158

Vegan
27 Mar 2022

Amazing tamales, great salsa, wonderful ambiance

Great place for vegans. Friendly staff, wonderful ambiance

Pros: Many vegan options, The tamales were wonderful , Guac and chips are great

thekickisgood

Points +163

Vegan
08 Aug 2021

Great vegan option in heart of Key West

Has vegetariansection on menu and In both of our visits they been incredibly accommodating in checking with the kitchen what is vegan as is and what could be modified by removing dairy. Outdoor seating. Good drinks.

Updated from previous review on 2021-08-08

Pros: Vegan friendly, Outdoor dining, Good location

ThatsVegayzing

Points +771

Vegan
08 Jan 2021

Vegan-Friendly Mexican in Key West

Food****
This restaurant is not a strictly vegan or vegetarian restaurant, but they were more than accommodating with changing dishes around and making sure we were happy with our food! We ordered the Spinach and Vegetable burrito and asked them to add black beans and Spanish rice; which they did free of charge! The strawberry margaritas were excellent as well and they even offer to-go drinks!

Service ****
As they were super accommodating with their menu, provided chips and salsa right away and had extremely quick service, they received a great review. COVID regulations were enforced and tables were far apart to ensure proper distancing.

Atmosphere ****
Restaurant is mostly outdoors although they do have a few indoor seats and a cute bar as well.
Cute decorations and lights hang from the trees to give it a great ambiance.

Price $$$
Dishes were average of $15 dollars and margaritas were around $8-12.

Pros: Very accommodating for vegans

Cons: Not strictly vegan

Susiesuse

Points +25

Vegan
19 Jan 2020

Good veg/vegan options

Good Mexican food with separate vegetarian section of the menu, most of which can be make vegan. Asked the server and the beans are cooked in water and sat, no pork broth.

Pros: Vegan Tamales were good!, Nice outdoor patio




This page has been viewed 3222 times.