New Jersey Pizza Company

  • Veg-options Veg-options
    ( 7 reviews )

2224 E Cedar Ave, Flagstaff, Arizona, USA, 86004

Serves meat, vegan options available. Uses local and organic produce, and is a slow food locally owned establishment. Produce selection is vast for a pizza place, roasted garlic, carmelized onions, and fire roasted tomatoes to name a few. Has vegan cheese and will make both pizzas and calzones with it. Open Mon-Sun 4:00pm-9:00pm.

Categories: Lacto, Ovo, Pizza, Italian, Organic, Delivery, Take-out, Non-veg

7 Reviews

First Review by baringforge


Points +45

11 Jun 2019

The Best Vegan Food I’ve Ever Eaten. - Edit

No Soy Curls Here. This place is legit. Affordable and on par with some of the best food I’ve eaten while living in Italy and Lebanon.

Pros: Many Vegan Options, Homemade Fermented Cashew Cheese, Italian, Middle Eastern and North African

Comment avatar

By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms


Points +78

04 Aug 2017

vegan pizza of my dreams - Edit

The atmosphere of this place is so nice. Cozy and authentic! When we got here I was a little worried we came to the wrong place because when glancing over the menu I couldn't find the vegan cheese anywhere! They had a cheese-less pizza, but as an unhealthy vegan i would always prefer my greasy vegan cheese 💁🏽. After asking the waitress she was sooo nice and attentive. She knew what she was talking about right away, and recommended we order the cheese less pizza with the vegan cheese, and she brought us a side of cold marinara sauce and balsamic and oil to dip our pizza in. I wish I remembered her name because she was really helpful. The vegan cheese was awesome. I believe she said it was soy based. All of the veggies were fresh, the crust was amazing, and our dips were so complimentary! We had a couple pieces left over and they were great even cold. (We were traveling so we didn't have an oven!) I would come here again in a heart beat. I wish I lived closer.

Comment avatar

By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms


Points +105

25 Jul 2017

Great Place! - Edit

Other than a bit of a wait time for the pies and calzone to be ready, this place is great. VEGAN cheese available, fresh toppings, with a crunchy outside but soft inside crust. Although cook time was
Slow, waiter was attentive with bringing over local brewed craft beers. Don't be in a rush if you come here.


Cons: slow cook time

Comment avatar

By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms


Points +20

09 Jul 2011

If you are vegan...go elsewhere. Rude , Unfriendly - Edit

My wife and I have tried to eat here twice. The hours are very weird...not open Saturday Afternoon...and yesterday we arrived at the 4 o,clock opening and had the entrance blocked by an extremely rude employee who said the ovens would not be warm enough to make pizza for another hour. The building is old and decrepit and appears to be filthy. We figured the hot pizza oven would likely kill the germs, but I never had a chance to evaluate if they can make a good Vegan pizza, because we were basically told to leave and not allowed to enter the building because the staff did not feel like making a Pizza at 4:00 PM. THEY DON'T WANT YOUR BUSINESS SO GO ELSEWHERE.

Pros: none

Cons: dirty , unfriendly , rude employees, hard to find on back. street

Comment avatar

By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms


Points +93

22 Aug 2009

NJP! - Edit

pizza without cheese isn't really worth purchasing. vegan cheese pizza on the other hand is awesome. new jersey pizza hooks it up with local and/or organic toppings whenever possible and everything is made from scratch (even their dairy mozzarella is made there which i think is impressive although i've never had it). this pizza is awesome- if you're in flagstaff you should definitely order a pie! i usually get it to go because it takes 45-80mins for them to make the pizza and the atmosphere in the dining room isn't too enjoyable. it's worth it if you order ahead :)

Pros: vegan cheese, local toppings, friendly staff

Cons: not a great sit-down place

Comment avatar

By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms


Points +43

08 Dec 2008

Awesome pizza - Edit

We stopped here on a cross country trip and the pizza is fantastic. The crust and sauce are excellent, and they used the right amount of soy cheese - they did not overdo it.

The ingredients are fresh and fantastic. My only disappointment was that I had hoped for some vegan pepperoni based on the earlier reviews. But they do not offer it as a topping any more.

Pros: Crust, Fresh ingredients, Vegan soy cheese

Cons: No more soy pepperoni

Comment avatar

By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms


Points +13

29 Apr 2008

incredible - Edit

I usually spend large blocks of vacation time seeking out great eating spots, particularly organic pizza joints. My prior favorite was "northwest pizza institute" in Eugene,OR, but NO MORE, as this place is now #1. The pizza here was incredible. The owner had all of the elements dialled in, and was very knowledgeable on all aspects. The crust and cheeses were primo quality. For example, the black olives weren't the typical canned/sliced olives normally found, but were actual real olives. The chevre on my pizza was tasty, and the crust was true to the style that they were going for, and perfectly done, not soggy, nor burnt. The storefront looked like some abandoned strip mall, with no sign announcing it's presence, yet it was still hopping on a monday afternoon, telling me the locals knew about the place. Do yourself a favor, and check this place out.

Pros: real ingredients, incredible friendly service, awesome organic buffalo wings

Cons: sign on the front would have been nice


22 Feb 2013
I'm hoping the organic buffalo wings you are referring to are organic vegetarian buffalo wings since this is a site dedicated to vegetarian dining. Thanks!
Comment avatar

By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms

Link to this page from your site. .
Return to Flagstaff Vegetarian Restaurants & Health Food Store Listings
Business Owners, if you see an unfair review, read this.
Why was my review removed? - details / Review guidelines
Reviews are not endorsed by HappyCow - review terms
Has New Jersey Pizza Company closed, shut down, moved, or changed? Please use the Update Form.
This page has been viewed 4190 times.