• Naturally Good Foods & Cafe

  • (13)
  • White Veg-options
Juice bar

Serves meat, vegan options available. Kitchen and juice bar inside the health food store. Offers grab n go food packaged in to-go ware. Vegans ask to omit cheese, etc. Kitchen closes 4pm. Open Mon-Wed 7:00am-5:00pm, Fri-Sat 7:00am-5:00pm, Sun 7:30am-4:30pm.

Venue map for Naturally Good Foods & Cafe
© OpenStreetMap contributors

13 Reviews

First Review by estefinparis


Points +169

21 Jun 2023

Amazing options and lovely store

Salads, wraps, burgers, cakes, soups - most with vegan options. Their vegan cheese is really good. One caution is they say as some vegans eat honey they don't automatically consider it non vegan so check as you order.

Great food, good tunes, lovely staff and good knowledge. Store is lovely for health food and organic groceries etc. Loads of seating out the front and back, restrooms.

Pros: Loads of options , Healthy and fresh, Seating and restrooms



Points +1205

05 Nov 2022

The best vegan option you’ll find in Montauk

Limited options but their wraps are good👌 It’s also a store so they have a bunch of good vegan snacks, drinks and fresh foods.


Points +22

12 Aug 2022

Best breakfast bagel ever

Great spot with tons of vegan options for breakfast and lunch. Nice grocery section too. The bagel with vegan cream cheese and sprouts is AMAZING.


Points +1761

12 Dec 2021

Limited vegan options in the area

I got the hummus wrap and chips. This place had a few more vegan options and is located in a store with vegan items.


Points +24

Mostly Veg
18 Jun 2021

Delicious Vegan Options

I let the cashier know that I was vegan and she explained the numerous options they had on their menu (and even mentioned she was vegan herself which was very relieving). I ordered the Cajun Tofu wrap with vegan cheese (which is what she recommended) and the Moroccan red lentil soup. It was the best meal I've had here in the Hamptons especially since most eateries here haven't been very vegan-friendly. They have many vegan options and items on the menu can be made vegan (just ask). Great food and great service. Definitely check this place out!

Pros: Lots of options, Delicious and flavorful food


Points +16

17 Feb 2021


Excellent food
And service. There are plenty of vegan options. Grocery store/deli.

Pros: Plenty of vegan options, Veggie based menu

Cons: Long lines in Summer season


Points +134

28 Sep 2020

Tofu burrito is one of the best!

Make sure you’re clear, but wow that burrito is a great price and superbly delicious. Small-ish, but AMAZING!

Add the vegan cheese and vegan sausage! So delicious


Pros: Great vegan burrito!

Cons: Breakfast ends at noon!!


Points +21

11 Aug 2020

Clarity is Key

I was really excited to order a vegan tofu breakfast burrito. After taking two bites I realized there was cheese on it even though I didn’t order vegan cheese as there is a surcharge of $1.50. Upon further exploration, the order taker assumed because I didn’t want the vegan cheese the regular cheese would stay on it. After discussing the situation they offered me to buy a new one, which didn’t rectify the situation in my mind. They should definitely have explicit vegan options on their menu as to not make this mistake.

Pros: Vegan options , Non dairy milks for coffee, Vegan scones

Cons: Unfriendly staff, No vegan specific items on menu


Points +32

26 Jul 2020

Great vegan option

I really appreciated this place. Amazing tofu scramble burrito, vegan veggie sausage and vegan bacon for breakfast. Much better than the tofu scramble at Joni’s. Will definitely go back for my morning breakfasts.

Pros: Kind staff, Delicious vegan options

Cons: Wish it had more of a sit-down restaurant vibe


Points +299

07 Feb 2020

A life saver when in Montauk.

Without this store/bakery, it would be very difficult to visit Montauk, especially during the winter months when most restaurants and cafes here are closed. It's a perfect place for a quick breakfast or lunch. There is a delicious tofu burrito on the menu (make sure to request that it be made vegan; it normally comes with dairy cheese, which they'll happily replace with vegan cheese). They also have a large selection of vegan cookies and muffins, as well as vegan cakes-in-a-cup and vegan chocolate truffles! The store also sells oat milk and soy creamer, as well as Amy's microwaveable pizzas, some of which are vegan.


Points +1771

08 Jun 2019

Love their food!

We’ve ordered a few things from Naturally good during our summers in Montauk, never disappointed. I get excited when I see the orange awning and know that food vegan eats await us! This most recent visit we actually went for dessert, they have plenty of vegan baked goods and also delicious coffee (and plenty of non dairy creamers and milks to choose from) I got a carrot cake in a cup with cream cheese frosting, to die for!

Pros: Outdoor seating, Plenty of options, Delicious food

Cons: Can be pricey - it’s Montauk


Points +112

26 Jan 2019


Naturally good is alright. Their vegan food is decent, but don’t expect chik’n or vegan eggs. As of the last time I was there, all of their vegan food was strictly vegetables. I would go back if I were hungry and in Montauk.

Pros: A few decent vegan options



Points +831

07 Jun 2017

Life saver in Montauk

This location combines a store with a great selection of organic products, including many vegan options, as well as a cafe with indoor and outdoor seating serving burgers, wraps, soups etc. Vegetarian items can be made vegan. Also serves juices and coffee. Food is pricey but very fresh and good quality. A life saver for vegans out in Montauk.

This page has been viewed 3613 times.