Vegan seasonal, add vegan cheese ! Super good at My Pie Pizzeria Romana - 72nd in New York City
Eggplant and mushroom truffle! Both amazing! at My Pie Pizzeria Romana - 72nd in New York City
Vegan slices at My Pie Pizzeria Romana - 72nd in New York City

  • CLOSED: My Pie Pizzeria Romana - 72nd
    (5)
    8

    Closed

  • White Veg-options
Lacto
Pizza
Italian
Delivery
Take-out
Non-veg

Serves meat, vegan options available. Roman pizza shop offering a few vegan slice options daily. Reported closed December 2021.

Leaflet | Protomaps | © OpenStreetMap contributors

5 Reviews

First Review by SamAnthony

Avatar Poundie

Poundie

Points +19395

Vegan
25 Sep 2021

Delicious vegan pizza

This is a small chain that offers pizza slices that are more artisanal than the typical slice place. I have always been satisfied with their vegan slices. They had three vegan choices when I visited last; I tried the truffle oil/mushroom vegan slice; it was delicious.

There is very limited indoor seating, but there is some functional, metal seats and tables outdoors, which they seem to share with Juicy Cube next door.

Pros: High quality pizza slices, Vegan choices, Good for takeout/quick bite

Cons: Not for refined dining out or relaxed meal.

front window at My Pie Pizzeria Romana - 72nd in New York City

Entire inside of venue at My Pie Pizzeria Romana - 72nd in New York City

Vegan slices at My Pie Pizzeria Romana - 72nd in New York City

Vegan truffle oil mushroom slice at My Pie Pizzeria Romana - 72nd in New York City

Avatar steveveg

steveveg

Points +3196

Vegan
07 Oct 2019

Several vegan options

My Pie had some very nice vegan pizzas, more than is shown in their online menu. I had the vegan no cheese pizza. The crust was thin and good. Service was friendly. There is very limited seating in this small shop.

Avatar Lindzar

Lindzar

Points +39

Vegan
31 Jul 2019

A great hole in the wall

Offers 3-4 vegan slices with vegan cheese as an add on. Pictured is the eggplant and mushroom truffle! Loved it.

Pros: Cheap, for what it is!, Good selection

Cons: Small, Hard to eat seating

Vegan seasonal, add vegan cheese ! Super good at My Pie Pizzeria Romana - 72nd in New York City

Eggplant and mushroom truffle! Both amazing! at My Pie Pizzeria Romana - 72nd in New York City

Avatar ChrisLich

ChrisLich

Points +167

Vegan
18 Jul 2019

Love this pizza.

I just had the truffle mushroom special and it was delicious. The slice was big too. I will be back for more

Avatar SamAnthony

SamAnthony

Points +1767

Vegan
26 May 2019

Ok vegan pizza

Loved that they have vegan slices! Sadly they're a bit disappointing. The vegan cheese used was not melted AT ALL - it was basically stringy, tasteless shreds that resembled cheese. The veggies on top were great and the square slices are huge but I think they should either not have any vegan cheese at all or learn how to cook it. There were some slices without the cheese so I'd recommend those instead.

Also note that this is Roman style pizza.

Pros: Vegan slices

Cons: Terrible use of vegan cheese

Vegan cheese slice at My Pie Pizzeria Romana - 72nd in New York City

Write Review Update Listing
For Members
Why was my review removed? Guidelines for writing a review View our privacy policy
For Business Owners
Claim this business See inaccurate information? Submit an update here Link to this page from your site See an unfair review? View full terms & conditions

This page has been viewed 0 times.