• Mitchell's Ice Cream

  • (6)
  • Ice-cream Ice Cream

Ohio based small chain of dairy ice cream parlors. Offers fruit-based sorbets and a couple of seasonal vegan flavors made from non-dairy source like coconut milk.

Venue map for Mitchell's Ice Cream
© OpenStreetMap contributors

6 Reviews

First Review by AlyssaEckles


Points +765

11 Jul 2022

Vegan Chocolate Cookie Butter

Only 3 vegan flavors. The vegan chocolate cookie butter was a seasonal flavor. It was creamy and delicious. My husband likes his vegan salted caramel pecan. Just wish they had more flavors.



Points +279

22 Jan 2022

Salted Caramel Pecan

Nice array of vegan options and almond milk milkshakes!🎈 Salted Caramel Pecan is bomb!

Pros: Handful of options


Points +175

21 Jun 2020

Many better options available

Mitchell's only has the same handful of vegan ice creams, none of which are outstanding. When I inquired about other flavors, especially a basic vanilla that would be more versatile than their plain (chalky) chocolate, I was told that they can only have four vegan flavors out of their total ***40*** flavors because people would complain if others were removed to make room for vegan options. Ok, I'm fine taking my business elsewhere!

Updated from previous review on 2018-11-28

Pros: None

Cons: Few vegan options which aren't even good


Points +16

27 Sep 2019


A great local company. The only flavor I have tried is chocolate. its nice and rich.also creamy. SO good. You will differently need some water after as it is very rich.


Points +335

02 Apr 2019

So good!

I love the atmosphere at this Michell's! My favorite is definitely the vegan salted caramel. Yum!


Points +132

Mostly Veg
01 Aug 2018

Two vegan flavors, but sooo good

So Mitchell's only offers two vegan flavors regularly, salted caramel and chocolate. However, they are some of the creamiest, loveliest ice creams you can get without dairy. Sweet, rich, and perfect for a summer day.

Also, they often have sorbet flavors, too, but those tend to depend on the season.

Pros: super tasty

Cons: only two options

This page has been viewed 1457 times.