• Mellow Mushroom

  • (13)
    17
    Loading...
  • White Veg-options
Vegan-friendly
Lacto
American
Pizza
Italian
Fast food
Beer/Wine
Delivery
Take-out
Non-veg

Serves meat, vegan options available. Hippie-themed, sit-down dining pizza restaurant. Has vegan cheese, tempeh for pizza and hoagies/sandwiches. Order from the pre-designed menu or build your own. Other menu options include a calzone and hummus and pita. Open Mon-Sun 11:00am-10:00pm.


13 Reviews

First Review by Vandekieft

Madisonian

Points +1527

Vegan
26 Aug 2025

Great vegan pizza and more

Great vegan pizza. We had the Veg Out, which was loaded with vegan cheese and veggies.

Some new vegan items on the menu since we last visited, including a tempeh hoagie, and a Greek salad. The server also offered the option of a veganized foccacia with vegan feta.

Huge portions, friendly servers.

2025 update: We tried the BBQ sauce with our tempeh pizza, one of several vegan sauces--spicy and delicious.

Updated from previous review on 2025-01-25

Pros: Great vegan pizza, Friendly servers, Generous portions

T.Jacobs108

Points +224

Vegan
16 Jun 2025

What an experience! Great food!

I tried their calzone which was absolutely delicious, great size and very filling. Me and my friend ended up getting some free pizza and my friend got a couple free beers when we were there! Great service and you can’t beat free add-ons 

mrnondairy

Points +47

Vegan
25 Nov 2024

BEST PIZZA I'VE EVER EATEN

As I said, it's the best!

I don't know how much care the chefs take with vegan orders—I can only express my sincerity as an ethical vegan and hope for respectful treatment. However, I have never found anything unwanted on my pizzas. Also, the sometimes amusingly informal staff will let slip silliness or intel; none have ever suggested any cause for concern. To the contrary, they have assured me that there is no reason to worry.

I'm not sure why I feel comfortable with pizza from non-vegan/vegetarian restaurants—it's my only exception. Mod Pizza feels the same, I just don't feel as anxious somehow. This place just makes me feel at ease, and the pizza is extraordinary.

Pros: BEST PIZZA I'VE EVER EATEN, Staff is fun and casual., Establishment is clean and well maintained.

Cons: It isn't a vegan only restaurant.

EliGrey57

Points +1251

Vegan
16 Aug 2024

Great Pizza

It's hard to find a vegan pizza that actually tastes like pizza. So I was more than surprised when I tasted their pie and realized that it actually tasted like the real thing. Not saying it was the best pizza ever, but it was a Pizza. I enjoyed every second of it.

kertheater

Points +43

Vegan
11 Aug 2024

3 visits, sick twice, perfect pizza once

I'm gluten free and vegan. It's a lot. Super inconvenient. I order a gluten free, vegan veggie pizza every time, every location.

The Chantilly Mellow Mushroom doesn't exactly have a winning streak with me.

First visit I was "glutened" and was quite sick.

Second visit, my pizza was PERFECT!!
No illness.
(But, my husband said when my pizza came out the first time it looked NOTHING like the pizza we ended up taking home. We don't know what was wrong with it but the take out person saw it and said it was wrong. The remake took a very long time. We had 2 drinks each before it was ready. So, I'm wondering if the host/take out person hadn't caught it would I have been sick 3 out of 3 visits??)

Third visit, my pizza had REAL DAIRY cheese! I realized immediately after my first bite. (It was also somehow quite cold?)
It's 2 am and I'm too sick to even try to go to bed yet.

I called, the manager said he would "take care of my pizza." I really should have asked him exactly what that meant, lol. He also said they would call back later to check on me? I thought that was weird but said ok. They never called.

Not sure I should give them a fourth try... :/

Pros: I like when my pizza is correct.

Cons: I am sick.

cstein40

Points +355

Vegan
27 May 2024

Easy

The menu is clear and the friendly staff understands the options. Easy quick pizza. Tastes like average pizza.

Pros: Easy menu, Quick, Knowledgeable staff

EricSeby

Points +88

Vegan
19 Mar 2023

Pizza is pretty top tier 😉

While the vibe felt hippie esque, the options were limited but don't let it stop you, bring along a beautiful date and enjoy! The other options while limited they seem delicious would try again!

Pros: Vegan pizza need I say more? , Very friendly wait staff, Prices weren't to shabby

Cons: Only cons are really the limited options

EricSeby

19 Mar 2023

ATXveganfam

Points +627

Vegan
05 Nov 2022

Fun place to eat out

I like the pizza and it’s a fun vibe.

Pros: Tempeh and tofu as pizza toppings , Vegan cheese

Cons: Service can be iffy

JenniferAshburn

Points +31

Vegan
10 Apr 2022

Vegan section on the menu!

We probably order the vegan veg out pizza twice a month, honestly. They use Follow Your Heart cheese and it's worth the price of the pizza!. They seem to be adding onto their vegan section, so I am excited about that!

SueCarter

Points +62

Vegan
29 Aug 2021

Food vegan food

But the service was pretty shoddy. 🤷🏻‍♀️

darkcellmp

Points +90

Vegan
22 Jul 2020

Can be good. A little expensive. Great staff.

We've had great vegan pizza here, and we've had some disappointing pizza here. It seems to vary.

However, one time we ate inside and our 2 year son didn't want to eat the pizza. We tried pasta, some plain bread bites, he wouldn't eat anything. They finally found an apple somewhere and cut it up into little slices for him to eat and he was happy. It wasn't until after we paid and left that we realized they didn't charge us for any of the food that our son didn't eat. The staff was already super nice and earned a well deserved tip from us, but I would have given them even more had I realized they didn't charge us for everything.

Pros: When done right, the vegan pizza is my favorite

Cons: Price is a bit high

EvaBrandan

Points +101

Vegan
20 Jun 2020

Good pizza!

I had a good experience here. Nice staff and tasty vegan pizza. A bit more on the expensive side, though.

Vandekieft

Points +326

Vegan
10 Mar 2020

Not worth the time

Disgusting droopy undercooked pizza. Even after we asked if they could cook it more it still wasn't cooked enough. Some decent vegan options but all had an off taste. Only thing my family actually enjoyed was the drinks that you can get anywhere.

Pros: Topping options

Cons: Quality, Taste, Staff, mostly kitchen.




This page has been viewed 0 times.