I ordered build your own pizza with tomato sauce, mushroom medley mix, artichokes and fresh basil and it was one of the best pizzas I had! No cheese necessary, not even vegan cheese! It was so good, I could eat it every day! But there were many other vegan options on the island I wanted to try, so I wasn’t able to eat it again but I’d highly recommend!
Crust is just as good as any NYC slice shop - Edit
They were out of vegan mozz today, but the cheese-free was so good we’ll definitely be back later this week to try it. We had the Grass Cay without mozz and subbed in a truffle base instead of red just to mix it up. 👌
2 Reviews
First Review by tegosnell
VLF
Points +167
Amazing pizza - Edit
I ordered build your own pizza with tomato sauce, mushroom medley mix, artichokes and fresh basil and it was one of the best pizzas I had! No cheese necessary, not even vegan cheese! It was so good, I could eat it every day! But there were many other vegan options on the island I wanted to try, so I wasn’t able to eat it again but I’d highly recommend!
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2025-12-30
Pros: The quality and taste of food! , Right in Cruz Bay, Cool place. Food served on gorgeous stoneware plat
Cons: It took a long time to make a pizza, it was busy. , Tables have signs to not stay longer than 90 min. , Busy place with lots of people
Guest
tegosnell
Points +16
Crust is just as good as any NYC slice shop - Edit
They were out of vegan mozz today, but the cheese-free was so good we’ll definitely be back later this week to try it. We had the Grass Cay without mozz and subbed in a truffle base instead of red just to mix it up. 👌
Read morePros: Solid crust, Great drinks , Dog friendly patio
Cons: Out of vegan mozz today
Guest
For Members
Why was my review removed? Guidelines for writing a review View our privacy policyFor Business Owners
Claim this business See inaccurate information? Submit an update here Link to this page from your site See an unfair review? View full terms & conditionsThis page has been viewed 1179 times.