Keeping You Sweet

Double chocolate, red velvet, raspberry shortcake, blueberry cheesecake, piña colada and carrot cake at Keeping You Sweet in Wayne

Keeping You Sweet
(3)
3

Loading...
Bakery

Vegan-friendly

Lacto

Ovo

Take-out

Bakery

A traditional bakery serving desserts with a healthy twist, cupcakes, cheesecakes and more. Vegan choices are clearly advertised on the website and include cheesecake, brownies and cake. Open Mon-Thu 11:00am-8:00pm, Fri-Sat 11:00am-9:00pm, Sun 11:00am-7:00pm.

Add Review Add Photos

Call
Website

1400 Willowbrook Mall (at Kiosk 5586), Wayne, New Jersey, USA, 07470
Loading...
+1-833-597-9338
keepingyousweet.com
- Last update on 11 Nov 2025 by harutan
  Update business info
- Are you the owner?
  Claim this business
- Added by varbuckle1 on 07 Jul 2023
Add Review Add Photos

3 Reviews

First Review by JamieLynCulotta

harutan

Points +53

Vegan

21 Dec 2024

Needs some changes - Edit

I have been coming to this place for a while and things have been getting worse. They were literally reselling Abe’s Muffins for like $3 or something similar. For one tiny muffin. The cookies are soooo thin now, its ridiculous. Almost always their cupcakes are very dry. I hope they change for the better. Until then, sadly, I cannot justify going back.

Pros: Variety

Cons: Dry baked goods, Reselling packaged baked goods for higher price, Not a good value for what you get

KeepingYouSweet

25 May 2025

We recently came across your review from December 2024 and wanted to address a few things.

The vegan muffins, bagels, and croissants we offered were sourced from an outside vendor (like many shops and bakeries) and we never positioned them as part of our dessert line. Our core products—including our vegan and gluten-free cupcakes, cakes, and cheesecakes—were baked fresh in-house every morning. We've built our reputation on quality, and dryness has not been an issue reported by our customers.

While we respect your opinion, it’s important to base criticism on facts. We’re committed to high standards and will continue to serve our loyal customers with the level of care and quality they’ve come to expect.

Warm Regards,
Monica
Manager, Keeping You Sweet

varbuckle1

Points +45

Vegan

07 Jul 2023

Delicious - Edit

Fair price
Lots of variety

Pros: So happy to see all vegan treats at the mall, Gluten free options too

JamieLynCulotta

Points +164

Vegan

20 May 2023

Delicious vegan desserts! - Edit

There was a buy 5, get 1 free deal, so of course I had to take it since I was so excited about all the vegan treats. I got a blueberry cheesecake which was made with monk fruit instead of refined sugar and it was delicious… very blueberry forward. I also got a raspberry shortcake, piña colada cupcake, double chocolate cupcake, red velvet and carrot cake. These were all so good that I went back to let the owner know. Big fan! I can’t wait to have more next time I’m there.

Pros: Many options, Gluten free and healthier choices available , Delicious