CLOSED: Il Sedano Allegro

  • Vegetarian Vegetarian
    ( 11 reviews )
Hours

Closed

Contact
552344020
Find

Via Farini 1/3 r, Florence, Italy, 50121

Vegetarian restaurant est. since 1990. Relaxed atmosphere on a quiet street, 2 blocks from Ospedale Santa Maria Nuova. Uses egg and dairy. CONFIRMED CLOSED, OCT 2016. Open Mon-Sun 12:00am-12:00am, Mon-Sat 7:30am-12:00am, Sun 7:00pm-12:00am.

Category: Lacto, Ovo, Italian, Mediterranean, Beer/Wine

Reviews (11)

First Review by Katiuscia

Mediocre - Edit

I had a onion soup and a dish with seitan.
The dishes were okay, but nothing special.
Staff is kind.


By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms

Gourmet Vegetarian - Edit

Everything is vegetarian. There is no tuna like someone claimed in a prior review.

The atmosphere is very nice. Dimly lit with candles on the tables, attractive furniture, and an attentive staff. My order seemed gourmet. This has pros and cons. The cons, as anyone who has eaten gourmet food, is that portions are smaller than normal and it's pricey. But the flavors were *amazing*, and the visual presentation was very good. I have never had anything like this ever. Great for a unique treat. They also gave me a free small glass of champagne. The server was also very friendly.

If you are in Italy looking for something cheap with large portions or something akin to the Olive Garden then don't go here and instead go to a restaurant with the word "trattoria" in the name. If you are in Italy look for gourmet quality vegetarian food at gourmet prices then this is the place for you.

I give it five stars because it's excellent for what it tries to be. (I think some of the reviews here gave it unfair bad marks because they walked into a gourmet restaurant expecting something more akin to the Olive Garden! That's like giving a gourmet Mexican restaurant a bad review because you expected Taco Bell prices.)

If I lived here (which I don't) I probably wouldn't eat there regularly due to the price, but I think it's well worth at least one or two visits for anyone visiting the city.


Updated from previous review on Thursday September 24, 2015

So I went there again and my second dish wasn't quite as gourmet-ish tasting as the first. This time it just felt overpriced. So I'm giving it 4 stars. I definitely recommend you order a side dish with the main course due to the portions.

Pros: Delicious!!, Some menu items are very unique., Romantic atmosphere.

Cons: Pricey., Small portions.


By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms

Good meal-nice atmosphere - Edit

This is one of the few relatively large vegetarian restaurants in Florence so that you are relatively sure of getting a table even without a reservation. The food was quite good though somewhat more expensive than other places (in contrast to other reviews, I don't think the portions are small). I had the eggplant parmagiane which was excellent. My partner had the skewed seitan, also good. There is both indoor and outdoor seating and it seems to be quite popular with the locals. It is located opposite the synagogue and not far from the Accademia (about a 15 minute walk).

Pros: good food, nice ambiance

Cons: somewhat expensive


By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms

Don't go there - Edit

Poor quality of the food, small portions, plain flavours,... Will not go there again. There are much better options. Too expensive for what it was...

Pros: Friendly staff, Nice terras

Cons: Poor quality, Small portions , Plain food


By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms

Give it a go! - Edit

It was a pleasant surprise. Lovely food for a great price. The service was good as was seating.
The menu selection is quite limited but changes regularly.

Pros: Good Food, Good Service, Good Price

Cons: Limited selection


By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms

glad it was there - Edit

Went for lunch at the end of October 2012. Pleasant staff and service, reasonable prices, some tasty dishes - bit to much reliance on seitan. Where are those pulses? would go again.


By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms

Great place, yum yum - Edit

We went to Sedano Allegro after finding that the Raccolta was closed for the summer - and what a find!

Had the seitan green curry, which was delicious, apparently the seitan is home made, and it was really tasty, not at all cardboardy like it can be sometimes, wish i could somehow ship it home...

They were very accomodating to my mum who can't eat oily things, and adapted a dish to suit.

Waiter spoke great English and service very good. Can't wait to go here agian.

Pros: Great food, Home made seitan, Acccmoodating to allergies

Cons: Bit out of the way


By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms

my favorite restaurant on the planet - Edit

Hm. I have traveled far, many times, to eat at Il Sedano Allegro (which means 'the happy celery' in Italiano); they do include the occasional shrimp on their menu, and yet it remains my favorite veg-esque restaurant anywhere, including my homeland of California, veg paradise. They serve a salad of avocado and hearts of palm, which drives me wild, along with extraordinary veg versions of Tuscan staples; an astonishingly tender seitan "boar" stew, and red pesto bombolotti are two favorites. For dessert, they serve my favorite crepe in the world: filled with apples, topped with pine nuts. I am overdoing it with the superlatives here; I can't help it. The food here is spectacular.

Also, the owners/chefs are terrifically warm hosts, and the ambience is fabulous, and uncommonly subtle/edgy for Italy: black and white collages (of antique movie stills, if I recall correctly) plaster the walls, and the terrace twinkles with holiday lights year round.

If you are a vegetarian into local/authentic Tuscan grazing, I suspect you will be awfully pleased with Il Sedano Allegro. Full disclosure: I usually end up relaxing my veganism when in Italy, i.e. not bothering to exclude dishes that may have eggs worked into the noodles, or cheese stirred into a sauce. So I can't totally vouch for the breadth of their pure vegan offerings.

Pros: insanely delicious, warm hospitality, charming ambience, authentic Tuscan food!

Cons: many dishes have dairy


By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms

Why Bother? - Edit

Many years ago this restaurant was the ONLY vegetarian restaurant in Florence at a time when vegetarian options at most restaurants were almost non-existent. As a result, Sedano Allegro developed a faithful clientele. But times have changed and now there are several excellent vegetarian restaurants here with imaginative menus focusing on seasonal vegetables and inspired seasonings. La Raccolta, open only at lunch, is an excellent example. These newer vegetarian restaurants offer excellent value and are always packed with satisfied customers. Nevertheless, Sedano Allegro remains fixed in the 1990's with their same tired menu and high prices. Pasta pomodoro? Melanzane alla parmigiana? Zuppa di vedura? PLEASE, USE SOME IMAGINATION!!!! Their menu is the same all year and does not vary with the seasons. In my opinion Sedano Allegro is more appropriate for carnivores who "occasionally" want to try something different. But the majority of the Sedano Allegro menu can be found at any regular Italian restaurant here in Florence, which almost all offer vegetarian options these days. However, for true vegetarians and vegans who eat a non-meat diet every day, this restaurant is sure to be a huge disappointment.

Pros: let me think ...

Cons: tired menu, high prices, boring


By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms

Not worth it!!! - Edit

You may like this restaurant only if you are occasionally a vegetarian and usually eat meat and fish. Here they serve food that might be appreciated only by someone who is new to a vegetarian diet. Not worth it! This restaurant has changed its location three times in less than ten years, but nothing has changed on their menu. I have sometimes eaten at this restaurant when it was one of the two vegetarian restaurants in Florence. Now there are others much better than this and I don't go there anymore. The current location is better than the previous ones, and the service is nice enough, but the food is nothing special. Almost everything seems to be prepared beforehand and warmed up just before being served. Prices are not low. There's no fantasy in any dish that they serve. Sometimes salads are with fish. I travel often and eat at many vegetarian/vegan restaurants all over the world. To me it's very clear that in this restaurant they don't really have a vegetarian cuisine culture. The last time I ate there was for Valentine's Day as they had heavily advertised a special dinner and dessert. It was even worst than at other times. Particularly the special cake presented like it was the grand finale of the Valantine's dinner! It was clearly a frozen cake (not well warmed!!), filled with something like a strawberry marmelade (really awfull!). There's something on the menu that they show as one of their specialities, called "bombolotti", but it's nothing more than a kind of pasta that you can find at the supermarket! So I really can't reccomand this place to anybody...

I'd like to say to the owner that being and eating vegetarian is much more than what they propose! Taking away turkey and bacon from a club sandwich... at the end you will only eat tomatoes and bread!

Pros: central location, friendly service

Cons: boring menu, not completely vegetarian, high prices


By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms

Not the best... - Edit

I'm not satisfied of this place. First of all, it could be a vegetarian restaurant but in the daily menu of today, there was salad with tuna fish. Then, I saw the waitress go to the kitchen with the original Worcester sauce and I'm sure that it isn't vegetarian because in the ingredients there are anchovies. I don't know where the sauce has been emploied, but on my salad there was an identified sauce that I didn't order, in doubt I didn't eat it. Then, the menu is a bit repetitive with a lot of seitan and cheese, but there isn't only one dish with legumes or tofu.
If I will return to Florence, I will not return here.

Pros: nice place

Cons: not good quality of food, a little pricey , small portions


By submitting this post you agree to HappyCow Terms

Link to this page from your site. .
Return to Florence Vegetarian Restaurants & Health Food Store Listings
Business Owners, if you see an unfair review, read this.
Why was my review removed? - details
Reviews are not endorsed by HappyCow - review terms
Has CLOSED: Il Sedano Allegro closed, shut down, moved, or changed? Please use the Update Form.
This page has been viewed 3437 times.