• CLOSED: Holey Moley Coffee and Doughnuts

  • (9)
    14

    Closed

  • Bakery Bakery
Bakery

Opened Jul 2014, this doughnut shop makes a few marked vegan doughnut flavors every day and has demand to make more from the locals. Could pre-ordered online to get a dozen's discount. Confirmed closed, Mar 2021.


Venue map for Holey Moley Coffee and Doughnuts
© OpenStreetMap contributors

9 Reviews

First Review by tauberl

Krystina

Points +259

Vegan
25 Jan 2020

Vegan cake donuts

Vegan cake donuts. They're good but don't really knock my socks off. They tend to sell out of the vegan options early. 5 of their 8 daily flavors are vegan. Every day of the week has a few (maybe 5 or so) additional flavors and usually one of those is also vegan. You can check out their weekly menu on their website. I'm pretty sure they change it up every season.

Pros: Clearly marked vegan options

Cons: Can sell out early

BrandyHuerta

Points +194

Vegan
29 Nov 2019

Tasty

They typically have several vegan donuts to choose from and they are all good. I was told they are working on having vegan croissants sometime soon 🦄

Pros: Good selection

Cons: All vegan donuts are usually cake, not yeast

realrachelsd

Points +131

Vegan
17 Nov 2019

Half of their donuts were vegan!

They had probably had 14 different donuts when I went in bag of which were vegan. I had pumpkin spice, chocolate cake and funfetti all of which were awesome.

Pros: Lots of vegan options , Cute concept , Great service

Kplant

Points +4013

Vegan
21 Apr 2019

Love me a Donut

Easy to get to and fast line to purchase. Lemon poppy seed was my favorite next to the spice cake.

Pros: 5+ options

Cons: Apple fritter not vegan

Mpveg

Points +334

Vegan
28 Jan 2018

come for the donuts!!!!

Still amazing another year later.... Since going vegan 2 years ago I have not found a place with vegan donuts--until today! They had four friendly options today-I've tried 3 so far and I have to say they were perfect. I liked the vanilla glazed chocolate cake and the blood orange better than the cinnamon sugar but all are great. I still have to try the raspberry but I'm full so it will have to wait. ;)
The coffee is nothing spectacular, but they have organic soy milk so I'm happy for that.
I'd come back for the donuts!!!

esther802535

Points +313

Vegan
01 Jan 2017

Vegan Saturdays are a must go!

I ordered a dozen of their vegan donuts to go - and I’m glad I did because they sell out fast. They offer all flavors vegan every Saturday, and I believe one a day every other day. They were all so good. Customer service was a bit lacking because I had been having many issues with their online ordering service (it wasn’t working at all and they were not very helpful), but they ended up making an exception and letting me order through e-mail, which was greatly appreciated. Definitely recommend for vegans in the MKE area.

Pros: Vegan Saturdays, Valentine Coffee

Cons: Lacking customer service

wolowoloman

Points +80

Vegan
07 Dec 2016

Wouldn't even know they're vegan. A++

Fantastic tasting vegan donuts! They don't even advertise that they're vegan since I'm sure some would just assume they're worse, but they're just like normal donuts {if not better!)!!
Great selection available throughout the week, but especially on the weekend (11 of the 15 donuts were vegan). Make sure to come before 10am because they sell out quick!

Pros: Just as good, if not better, than "normal" donuts, Healthy, wholesome ingrediants , Variety of vegan donuts

Cons: Sell out quick!

JesseIves

Points +133

Vegan
22 Oct 2015

really good doughnuts

If you are vegan, they usually have 3 flavors for you, but if you go on Saturday they call it "vegan Saturday" and have a long list of flavors. We got there kind of late but were still able to get 4 different kinds. They were fantastic. Hopefully we can get there when they open on Saturday in the future.
Updated from previous review on Monday July 13, 2015
I recently got a doughnut at Miller Park during a baseball game, which I think is awesome that it is even an option, but unfortunately it tasted like deep fryer.
I don't get to Holey Moley very often because of the hours and my schedule, but it's really unfortunate when you get a bad one that doesn't encourage you to go back for a time.

Pros: good selection

Cons: run out early

tauberl

Points +472

Vegan
24 Oct 2014

Amazing donuts!!

While it has become fairly easy to find a vegan cookie or cupcake, donuts were a little harder to come by...until now!! This place is awesome, they always have at least a few vegan flavors, and more on Saturdays; they seem to be experimenting with different flavors, so new ones keep getting added! Most are cake, which are dense and delicious, but last weekend there was also a raised yeast maple pecan!! It was great. The chocolate cake vegan one is my favorite so far, but really every one that I've tried has been excellent. They are also really open to comments and feedback, I am currently lobbying for a vegan pumpkin donut. Go here for amazing vegan donuts!!!




This page has been viewed 4719 times.