• Gotham Bagels

  • (6)
    24
    Loading...
  • White Veg-options
Lacto
American
Take-out
Bakery
Non-veg

Serves meat, vegan options available. New York style bagels. Stocks 3 kinds of soy/tofu cream cheese. Open Mon-Sat 7:00am-3:00pm, Sun 8:00am-2:00pm.


Venue map for Gotham Bagels
© OpenStreetMap contributors

6 Reviews

First Review by shafess

izzyfrances

Points +264

Vegetarian
05 Mar 2023

Vegan cream cheese!

It's great to be able a classic bagel and cream cheese and it be vegan! The bagels are fresh and pretty big, so it's great value for money.

vegan_mar

Points +161

Vegan
22 Aug 2021

4.5 stars!

I love Gotham and go there every time i’m in Madison. The tofu cream cheese is heavenly and the bagels are really good. Be sure to ask for your toasted bagel vegan or dont get it toasted because a few times i’m pretty sure I tasted butter on my bagel from the toasting it.

The staff, especially the owner, are often rude. Not sure if that’s his personality or part of the “experience”. I don’t personally like that vibe but the bagels are so good that I keep coming back and try to interact with the owner as little as possible 🙃

berkeleyvegan

Points +26

Vegan
06 Apr 2021

Pretty good

One of the better bagels in Madison, but would probably be considered mid-tier in other big cities. Good vegan tofu cream cheese options.

happycowgirl

Points +5631

Vegan
07 Jul 2018

Sorry Not Sorry

I went here once. The tofu cream cheese is indeed amazing!! That’s the best thing about this place. Unfortunately, for me everything else sucked. Starting with the rude service. The guy who took my order was a total d*ck. His generally-pissed-off-at-the-world vibe seemed to be shared by all the employees. The music was bad. My bagel was stale. Maybe it was just an off day for them and you’ll have a better go of it.

ErinLowry

Points +95

Vegan
14 Mar 2018

Surprising Vegan Options

These are the best bagels in town, imagine my surprise when they also offer Tofu Spread instead of Cream Cheese! Love this place.

shafess

Points +600

Vegan
10 Apr 2017

Great stop for breakfast

The bagels were super delicious and the tofu spread was surprisingly good. I'd never had a spread like that and they slathered it on thick, which was great. Good way to end a weekend trip to Madison!

Pros: Delicious spread, Good bagels

Cons: Needs more options




This page has been viewed 3810 times.