• CLOSED: Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop

  • (6)
    3

    Closed

  • Bakery Bakery
Vegan-friendly
Lacto
Ovo
American
Take-out
Asian
Bakery
French
Honey

South 91 location. A bakery with a contemporary atmosphere offers many vegan breads and baked goods. The sandwich menu rotates monthly; ask for the vegan option. Reported closed December 2023.


Venue map for Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop
© OpenStreetMap contributors

6 Reviews

First Review by Rasputin

rosekreider

Points +96

Vegan
20 Dec 2023

Great bread

Great bread. Unfortunately no vegan sandwich option.

laurmott

Points +26

Vegetarian
25 Aug 2023

Cute and trendy

Limited veggie options. The team said they decided not to make the veggie breakfast sandwich that day so only the lunch sandwich was available. It did look like they had a focaccia that was veggie friendly though.

kalden67

Points +111

Vegan
26 Jul 2023

Limited Vegan

Good vegan shortbread of the day but considering the non-vegan selection it’s kinda disappointing.

Pros: Vegan shortbread

Cons: Lack of options , Rushed order environment

Jadediana

Points +2608

Vegan
27 Apr 2022

No actual vegan options

Disappointed to find no vegan options but the bread. Guy at the counter kept trying to sell us vegetarian options when we explicitly asked for vegan options telling us all about their options with egg… so we left pretty quickly after that.

Sarah P

Points +8583

Vegan
27 Feb 2021

Excellent sandwich

I found out there is a monthly rotating sandwich menu, and there is one vegan OR vegetarian option per month. Luckily this month the option was vegan. The black bean avocado sandwich was incredible, I wouldn’t change a thing. Even though it looked kind of small, it turned out to be an ample hearty meal, with lots of vegetables. If you are going to be in the area and want a really good sandwich it’s worth calling or looking online to find out the offering.

Pros: Delicious quality , Near a shopping area you might be , Super friendly service

Cons: Very limited vegan options

Rasputin

Points +530

Vegan
17 Dec 2020

Best Bahn Mi

These guys make the best vegan bahn mi I have ever had the privilege of tasting - Could not be improved! Et les pain de campagne est parfait!

Pros: Great Food, Contemporary Atmosphere




This page has been viewed 1561 times.