Contact
414-727-0761
Serves meat, vegan options available. Has vegan pizza or could build-your-own. Topping choices include veggie sausage and tofu, vegan cheese (ask for it). Can also substitute the vegan cheese in the calzone. Open Mon 11:00am-10:00pm, Tue-Sat 11:00am-12:00am, Sun 11:00am-10:00pm.
Categories: Vegan-friendly, Lacto, American, Pizza, Beer/Wine, Delivery, Take-out, Non-veg
8 Reviews
First Review by saidinjest
Contributions +64
pizza! - Edit
Who doesn’t like pizza? Thursday is their vegan special night (free soy breadsticks with a vegan pizza pie purchase). I come here pretty often and am usually happy. The have a shaker of nutritional yeast next to the red pepper flakes & stuff, so be sure to give your slice an extra shake of this stuff when you get it. I love the atmosphere. They do delivery. Super friendly. I usually build my own slice, but they have pre-figured-out vegan combos on their menu.
Contributions +24
yummy!!! - Edit
Large slices! My veggie pizza had scrambled tofu & vegan cheese on it. Good texture, perfect amount of crunch, fresh veggies, no complaints. board games & coloring books & arcade games. Cool atmosphere.
Contributions +617
Don't miss this place. - Edit
Traveling from out of town, we had time for one more meal before leaving Milwaukee. We decided to try this pizzeria. What fun. The slices of pizza are huge. You actually get a mini-sized pizza in the shape of a huge slice. 2 slices are roughly the equivalent of a small pizza anywhere else. The choices for toppings are beyond the usual - jalapenos, cilantro, etc. Great taste. Vegan options. Very unusual and interesting salads.
Contributions +563
Great Vegan Pizza - Edit
We've eaten at Classic Slice several times now and love it there. The slices are huge and good with or without the vegan cheese. It's always fast, they have several specifically vegan pizza options (and you can make your own) and also have some really good soy stix (cheesy bread sticks). A bit pricey but worth the splurge every once in a while.
Pros: Great pizza, Fast service
Cons: A bit pricey
Contributions +466
Yummy pizza, huge slices! - Edit
Great vegan slices, I especially like the Anne Curry with curry sauce and tofu! Their breadsticks and calzones can also be made vegan, and they often have vegan baked desserts (cupcakes). The portion sizes are huge, so go hungry!
Pros: Clearly labeled vegan options, Huge portion sizes, Friendly staff
Contributions +69
Classic Pizza-yep. - Edit
I enjoy eating at Classic Slice. It is not in my neighborhood but they seem to cater to many community and activist events always providing vegan pizza! For Milwaukee, that is amazing! When I have dined in, the staff and atmosphere have been very pleasant. I like the personal flair to the photos in the hallway leading to the restrooms- which have always been immaculate. (Have you noticed reviewers freaking out about restrooms on this site?) Anyway, if your looking for pizzeria pizza that is vegan, in Milwaukee I would send you no where else.
Pros: great pizza, friendly atmosphere, involved in community
Cons: a little pricey
Contributions +36
Not too bad! - Edit
I've eaten Classic Slice a lot and they're pretty good. I do get sick of the same 3 vegan specialty pizzas though. It would be nice if they expanded that selection. They do deliver though, so that's a plus! They also have Follow Your Heart vegan cheese, but they charge extra for it and you only get a sprinkling of it over the top of the pizza.
Pros: Delivery, Mini pies, bread sticks
Cons: Limited specialty pizzas
Contributions +48
Vegan Pizza! - Edit
As the name suggests, Classic Slice sells pizza by the slice. Unfortunately, they won't make the slices without cheese, so if you want to a vegan pizza, you have to order a 9" mini pie (which is about the size and price of 2 slices) or a whole pizza. They do have vegan pizzas listed right on their menu, including a Super Veggie (with red sauce, mushrooms, broccoli, spinach, fresh basil and either tofu or vegan sausage), the Anne Curry (curry sauce with broccoli, spinach, mushrooms, tomatoes and tofu) and the Mediterranean pizza (olive tapenade with sundried tomatoes, spinach, mushrooms and vegan sausage). It's not on their menu for some reason, but they also offer vegan cheese, which is Follow Your Heart mozzarella. If I could change one thing, I'd suggest they use Daiya cheese or even Teese instead of the FYH cheese (and that they mention the vegan cheese on their menu), but the fact that they offer it at all is pretty awesome. Their pizza dough and red sauce are both very delicious. The breadsticks are also vegan, and they're basically just pizza dough with olive oil and lots of garlic. Calzones can be made vegan as well.
Pros: Delivery, Vegan cheese, Non-chain restaurant
Cons: Sometimes slow, Serves dead animals and their secretions, Should put vegan cheese on their menu
Link to this page from your site. Entry info .
Return to Milwaukee Vegetarian Restaurants & Health Food Store Listings
Business Owners, if you see an unfair review, read this.
Why was my review removed? - details / Review guidelines
Reviews are not endorsed by HappyCow - review terms
Has Classic Slice Pizza closed, shut down, moved, or changed? Please use the Update Form.
This page has been viewed 1810 times.
Nearby Listings
View MoreHoneypie Cafe
Palomino Bar
Outpost Natural Foods - Bay View
Cafe Corazon - Kinnickinnick
Babes Ice Cream