• Classic Slice Pizza

  • (15)
  • White Veg-options

Serves meat, vegan options available. Has vegan pizza or could build-your-own. Topping choices include veggie sausage and tofu, vegan cheese (ask for it). Can also substitute the vegan cheese in the calzone. Open Mon 11:00am-10:00pm, Tue-Sat 11:00am-12:00am, Sun 11:00am-10:00pm.

Venue map for Classic Slice Pizza
© OpenStreetMap contributors

15 Reviews

First Review by saidinjest


Points +76

06 Aug 2023


The slices were large but were amazing.

Pros: Size , Customer service , Location

Cons: Bland, Not many options



Points +526

27 Nov 2022

Good, local pizza spot

Always consistent vegan options. They put forth just enough effort to make good vegan options, but not nearly enough compared to their other options. A great option when ordering for several different dietary needs for a group.

Recently found that the garden veggie was removed from the menu, which was a favorite of ours.

Pros: Separate veg section of the menu

Cons: Long wait times. Typically 45-60 min


Points +121

30 Aug 2022

My Go-To Pizza Place

VEGAN CINNAMON ROLLS! This is my pizza place of choice since they offer the best vegan pizza anywhere. Imagine my surprise while I was waiting to pay for my pizza my gaze wandered over to the drinks case and I saw some vegan cinnamon rolls! What? Where did THESE come from? Apparently, some employee makes them, I think they mentioned a woman's name. I bought my pizza, bought the rolls and had a thoroughly enjoyable meal. Those buns were terrific. I had a friend make me her version of vegan Cinnabons a couple times, but I have to say - Classic Slice's vegan cinnamon rolls beat hers! (Written in 2012)


Points +21

16 Feb 2022

Classic taste with modern options.

Vegetarian, so red sauce, pesto, spinach and vegan sausage. Highly recommend. The Brussels sprouts were great too, although a bit of a strange option in the setting! Canned and bottled beers, no draft.

Pros: Vegan Italian sausage is amazing!, Sauces (Red and Pesto) both great!, Inviting and inclusive.

Cons: No draft beers.


Points +132

05 Nov 2019

Amazing salads!!! Great vegan pizza options!!!

This is our favorite local pizza place. So many vegan options. The avocado and modern love salads are so good.

Pros: Lots of vegan options , Thursday vegan specials, Fancy salads


Points +237

22 Sep 2019

skip the cheeze

The pizza was good but honestly significantly better without the cheeze they put on it. I have the pesto and scraped the soy cheese.


Points +153

14 Oct 2018

So many options!

Friendly staff. So many options, even soy cheese sticks!

Pros: Vegan protein, Vegan cheese, Speciality made options


Points +26

25 Jun 2018

go here now!

Super relaxed and TONS of vegan options. Vegan cheez is made in house. Yumtastic!


Points +259

12 Nov 2017


Who doesn’t like pizza? Thursday is their vegan special night (free soy breadsticks with a vegan pizza pie purchase). I come here pretty often and am usually happy. The have a shaker of nutritional yeast next to the red pepper flakes & stuff, so be sure to give your slice an extra shake of this stuff when you get it. I love the atmosphere. They do delivery. Super friendly. I usually build my own slice, but they have pre-figured-out vegan combos on their menu.


Points +24

28 May 2017


Large slices! My veggie pizza had scrambled tofu & vegan cheese on it. Good texture, perfect amount of crunch, fresh veggies, no complaints. board games & coloring books & arcade games. Cool atmosphere.


Points +712

21 Dec 2015

Don't miss this place.

Traveling from out of town, we had time for one more meal before leaving Milwaukee. We decided to try this pizzeria. What fun. The slices of pizza are huge. You actually get a mini-sized pizza in the shape of a huge slice. 2 slices are roughly the equivalent of a small pizza anywhere else. The choices for toppings are beyond the usual - jalapenos, cilantro, etc. Great taste. Vegan options. Very unusual and interesting salads.


Points +458

13 Jan 2014

Yummy pizza, huge slices!

Great vegan slices, I especially like the Anne Curry with curry sauce and tofu! Their breadsticks and calzones can also be made vegan, and they often have vegan baked desserts (cupcakes). The portion sizes are huge, so go hungry!

Pros: Clearly labeled vegan options, Huge portion sizes, Friendly staff


Points +69

12 Jul 2010

Classic Pizza-yep.

I enjoy eating at Classic Slice. It is not in my neighborhood but they seem to cater to many community and activist events always providing vegan pizza! For Milwaukee, that is amazing! When I have dined in, the staff and atmosphere have been very pleasant. I like the personal flair to the photos in the hallway leading to the restrooms- which have always been immaculate. (Have you noticed reviewers freaking out about restrooms on this site?) Anyway, if your looking for pizzeria pizza that is vegan, in Milwaukee I would send you no where else.

Pros: great pizza, friendly atmosphere, involved in community

Cons: a little pricey


Points +36

01 Apr 2010

Not too bad!

I've eaten Classic Slice a lot and they're pretty good. I do get sick of the same 3 vegan specialty pizzas though. It would be nice if they expanded that selection. They do deliver though, so that's a plus! They also have Follow Your Heart vegan cheese, but they charge extra for it and you only get a sprinkling of it over the top of the pizza.

Pros: Delivery, Mini pies, bread sticks

Cons: Limited specialty pizzas


Points +48

18 Nov 2009

Vegan Pizza!

As the name suggests, Classic Slice sells pizza by the slice. Unfortunately, they won't make the slices without cheese, so if you want to a vegan pizza, you have to order a 9" mini pie (which is about the size and price of 2 slices) or a whole pizza. They do have vegan pizzas listed right on their menu, including a Super Veggie (with red sauce, mushrooms, broccoli, spinach, fresh basil and either tofu or vegan sausage), the Anne Curry (curry sauce with broccoli, spinach, mushrooms, tomatoes and tofu) and the Mediterranean pizza (olive tapenade with sundried tomatoes, spinach, mushrooms and vegan sausage). It's not on their menu for some reason, but they also offer vegan cheese, which is Follow Your Heart mozzarella. If I could change one thing, I'd suggest they use Daiya cheese or even Teese instead of the FYH cheese (and that they mention the vegan cheese on their menu), but the fact that they offer it at all is pretty awesome. Their pizza dough and red sauce are both very delicious. The breadsticks are also vegan, and they're basically just pizza dough with olive oil and lots of garlic. Calzones can be made vegan as well.

Pros: Delivery, Vegan cheese, Non-chain restaurant

Cons: Sometimes slow, Serves dead animals and their secretions, Should put vegan cheese on their menu

This page has been viewed 4029 times.