Serves meat, vegan options available. 3 Brothers offers several branches across Long Island. Brick oven pizzeria opened since 2013. Has a separate and extensive vegan menu created by one of the sons, Jay, that features many choices, from pizza with vegan cheese & mock meats to burgers, hoagies, pasta, and other Italian entrees. Brunch menu on weekends. NOTE: Please verify if vegan options are available every day at all times. Open Tue-Thu 11:00am-10:00pm, Fri-Sat 11:00am-11:00pm, Sun 11:00am-10:00pm.
-
75 Merritts Rd, Farmingdale, New York, USA, 11735
-
Loading...
-
- Wheelchair accessible
- Accepts credit cards
-
-
Last update on 10 Mar 2023 by ezhik21
Update business info -
Are you the owner?
Claim this business
-
-
47 Reviews
First Review by Jess McNeill
JackieGleason
Points +201
Vegan menu - Edit
They have a separate vegan menu with many options. The food is delicious. There is a regular menu for non vegans. We were the only ones eating lunch. Many take food out. There was a problem with the electronic paying system which delayed our leaving by at least 10 min. They couldn't get it to work. They suggested we go to an ATM to get cash to pay the bill which didn't make us happy. We ended up pooling our money together. This soured us on going back again.
Read morePros: Separate vegan menu, Delicious food, Very nice bus boy (man)
Cons: Faulty electronic payment system
Guest
Gast3riH0e
Points +45
Delicious Food - Edit
Great portions and lots of great options. There are not a lot of vegan Italian-American spots in eastern Long Island but this is the closest one besides Pazzo Pizzeria and it really hits. Also prices are decent depending on what you order.
Read morePros: Charming location next to the train tracks, Price is either less than or the same as others
Cons: A bit out of the way from downtown Farmingdale, Not all vegan
Guest
Nutzrgood4u
Points +79
Pizza nicely done - Edit
Vegan menu ask for it. Lots of premade pizza choices on display clearly marked. I loved their other sit down location south shore went offline. This one is great folks but the parking here is uggh.
Read moreOk appetizers all tasty, love their trio option to pick and choose. Heroes and clone and burger good stuff. All your Italiano entrees made vegan are spectacular.
Pizzas lot of menu choices, your call. All awesome. They get the full 5 stars but the cow say only for fully vegan. Hey don't miss this place. The one sister store in Rockville on sunrise hwy is a take out only so co.w to Farmingdale if eating in.
Desserts are listed on the counter of what's available. Good options here. Choco bomb it.
Pros: Food, Friendly and knowledgeable staff, Did I say the food?
Cons: Parking or hard to get small lot, Inside your seating can be limited but sufficient
Guest
Orangerory
Points +101
Great vegan options - Edit
 This place has an extensive vegan menu with all of your favorite Italian dishes veganized and ginormous portions. I am in town on business and was looking for a vegan friendly option on Uber eats. This hit all the high marks. The food was delicious.
Read morePros: Eggplant rollatini, Seitan piccata , Garlic knots
Cons: Caesar salad was meh. Skip it. , Too much food!
Guest
vegancatlady77
Points +1355
Delicious vegan options - Edit
I visited a few years ago and they had many vegan options. The food we had was delicious.
Read morePros: Vegan options
Guest
KeiryAyala
Points +53
♡︎love this place - Edit
One of my favorite vegan places on Long Island. It is so convenient and delicious every time go here every time I’m in Farmingdale had most of the pizza flavors. All good and the brunch menu delicious!!! The portion sizes are great as well. 
Read moreGuest
AnnalieseTech
Points +637
My Vegan Transition Restaurant - Edit
Ah, 3 Brothers Pizza Cafe! Let me take you on a journey down memory lane, back to the beginnings of my vegan odyssey, where this quirky little pizzeria stood as a beacon of hope in a sea of cheese-covered despair.
Read morePicture it: a bustling street corner, the scent of marinara wafting through the air like a siren's call, and there it was, 3 Brothers Pizza Cafe, standing proud and unassuming, like a wise old sage in the world of plant-based delights.
From the moment I crossed the threshold, I knew I was in for a treat. The separate vegan menu beckoned like a treasure map, promising culinary delights beyond my wildest dreams. Brunch, lunch, dinner, desserts—no mealtime was left unturned in their quest to satisfy even the most discerning herbivore.
And oh, the desserts! Don't even get me started on the heavenly creations sourced straight from Vegan Treats. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, a testament to the power of cruelty-free indulgence. From decadent cakes to tantalizing pastries, it was a dessert lover's paradise.
But perhaps what truly set 3 Brothers apart was the personal touch. Despite the passage of time, the owner still recognized me, a testament to the enduring bond forged over countless meals shared in vegan bliss. It was like coming home to family, if your family happened to serve up mouthwatering plant-based fare with a side of nostalgia.
Of course, no establishment is without its quirks, and 3 Brothers was no exception. While the menu remained a stalwart bastion of vegan delights, there was a distinct lack of innovation when it came to shaking up one's taste buds. It's like they found the recipe for success and stuck to it like glue, leaving us hungry adventurers yearning for a taste of the unknown.
Then there were the whispers, the rumors swirling around like cheese in a calzone. Harassment allegations among the female staff cast a shadow over the otherwise sunny ambiance, a reminder that even the most beloved eateries are not immune to the darker side of human nature.
And let's not forget the elephant in the room—or should I say, the appetizer prices. While I'm all for supporting local businesses and sustainable practices, shelling out an arm and a leg for a plate of hummus and veggies felt like highway robbery in broad daylight. A minor gripe, perhaps, but one that left a bitter taste in the mouth nonetheless.
Pros: Multiple food options, Vegan Treats dessert, Filling and tasteful
Cons: Expensive appetizer prices, Lack of menu innovations, Limited parking during peak hours
Guest
RebeccaSullivan
Points +6185
Good Food - Edit
Used to come here all the time. Haven’t been here in probably 5 or so years. Eggplant rollatini dinner was good.
Read moreGuest
kittychik79
Points +46
Great variety - Edit
Very tasty food. Good amount of food given. Eggplant rollatini is excellent. Also loved the cauliflower steak.
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2023-04-27
Pros: Lots of food
Cons: A tiny bit on the expensive side but not terrible
Guest
Jgatt
Points +2292
Delicious vegan menu! - Edit
Great restaurant with a very extensive vegan menu! Sooo many options. My favorite is the eggplant rollatini! Also awesome desserts
Read morePros: Nice atmosphere with cute dine in area
Guest
krissyxo
Points +25
Top notch! - Edit
3 Brothers is one of my favorite vegan restaurants. They have the best food selection. #Veganuary
Read morePros: Lots of vegan options , Fresh food
Guest
Tofruity
Points +31
Trashy owners - Edit
Some customers came in to tell the owners that there was a guy exposing himself in front of the store and they just tell them, it's not their problem.
Read moreWas some homeless guy they knew the by name and were feeding him who they valued more their their paying customers. What trash to put people through that.
Cons: Owners, Hostile towards women
Guest
nastyvegan
Points +588
Favorite for years - Edit
My favorite pizza. I walk out with way more slices than I need every time. Went for brunch today and I'm so stuffed!! Unfortunately they didn't have the vegan omelette today, so we got the scramble which was still delicious and fillings. Our server was sweet and efficient.
Read morePros: Family business , Always consistent
Cons: The main waitress has a tude every single time 😂
Guest
Suzanne262
Points +30
Amazing Vegan Food - Edit
I loved this restaurant! They have a separate vegan menu and everything I tried was delicious!! The Buffalo Drumsticks were very hot. The first bite was heaven, but then my lips were on fire. But they were too good not to finish! The Eggplant Rollatini was incredible! I highly recommend this restaurant. I’ll be back next time I visit Long Island.
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2021-08-05
Pros: Delicious vegan options
Guest
gml20
Points +13
SO GOOD!! - Edit
SO good. I wish I lived closer, I got takeout from here when I was working in the area. I’m from NJ but I will travel back just to eat here again. Vegan Mozzarella sticks were amazing. The large vegan pizza was the best vegan pizza I’ve ever had. If you’re craving pizza and miss the non-vegan pizza that you used to eat, this pie is the perfect fix.
Read moreGuest
Ameisherry
Points +13033
Nice vegan options - Edit
Their salad can be a great raw vegan options
Read moreThe cooking pan need to separate for cooking vegetables and seafood though because the sautéed spinach and eggplant Parmesan taste like fish 🐟
Updated from previous review on 2020-04-01
Guest
tfish
Points +4115
Excellent vegan options - Edit
I’ve eaten from here a few times — surprised I haven’t remembered to review it yet. Nice to have a whole big vegan Italian menu. Their penne alla vodka is incredible and I’d highly recommend you try it; the pizzas are great too. I will note that some of the dishes are actually not too great (I’m looking at you, seitan meatballs), but they’re still fine enough & the ones that are good are really great.
Read morePros: Some amazing dishes, Full vegan menu
Cons: Bit pricey
Guest
brendanf
Points +175
Solid stuff - Edit
Happy to stop in but not as good as their RVC location. Wide variety.
Read morePros: Variety, Usually good, Price decent
Cons: Less reliable
Guest
soularlover
Points +46
Disappointing - Edit
Ordered 2 GF pies last night and was hyping it up to my family until we saw them. But the size wasn't even what was most disappointing. The pizza itself tasted bland and the texture of the cheese... Sigh. We ordered 2 cannolis at 5 bucks a piece. Those were great, but I wouldn't get them again. Honestly, I'm currently deterred from this place.
Read moreGuest
Daynecism
Points +152
Very solid on LI - Edit
I usually can't eat Italian food when I come to LI, but it was great to find this place. Had the seitan parmesan, which was good. Prices are decent for an Italian place around here.
Read morePros: Tons of options, Meat alternatives and vegetable options
Guest
JMannion86
Points +16
My new favorite spot - Edit
They haven’t failed me once
Read morePros: Amazing Vegan pizza and other food, Great vegan brunch , Non vegan options to appease all
Cons: Kinda small area pizzeria style Not a lot of cozy
Guest
viajrs
Points +58
Best vegan pizza! - Edit
I tried them and had three different slices(don’t judge). I had a regular, the buffalo chikn and the bbq chikn with onions. Oh my goodness, it was amazing. I freaked out for a bit because I thought it had to be real cheese but you can tell it wasn’t but it was just incredible. I definitely recommend. $20 for the three slices- a bit pricey but not bad.
Read moreDid wish they used gloves though.. one of the guys was moving some pies around without gloves.
Guest
courtneyautera
Points +144
Excellent food and service - Edit
I ate here with my grandparents who aren’t vegan and it was good to see that they could get non-vegan food, while I got to choose from the separate vegan menu. My grandpa actually got a vegan dish and love it! All three of us enjoyed a slice of vegan cake too! The waitresses were kind to us and also very funny! I would recommend this restaurant to anyone, regardless of whether you are vegan or not. It’s a great place to eat at if you are vegan and want to go out with non-vegan friends or relatives as well!
Read morePros: Vegan and non-vegan options, Big menu, Excellent service
Cons: Expensive, Small dining area
Guest
gabandtonic
Points +3018
Vegan brunch is lovely - Edit
The vegan menu is probably the most extensive I’ve seen for a restaurant that is not 100% vegan.
Read morePros: The full vegan menu is varied , The pizza and wings are great
Guest
Nursejessica87
Points +324
Great vegan pizza! - Edit
We were fortunate to find vegan pizza while visiting in Long Island! And they delivered! Can’t complain.
Read morePros: Great vegan pizza
Guest
vanii.pinto
Points +38
Many tasty options - Edit
It is a small place with a good atmosphere. There is a whole separate vegan menu with lots of options for appetizers, main courses and desserts. If you're bringing nonvegan friends/family they have an equally big menu for them as well.
Read morePros: separate vegan and nonvegan menus, lots of options, friendly staff
Guest
mmorrison317
Points +29
The BEST - Edit
This is hands down the best vegan restaurant i have eaten at. I love the staff, the menu, the atmosphere. I have ordered from their catering menu on holidays. I absolutely love this restaurant.
Read moreCons: Need a location further east
Guest
For Members
Why was my review removed? Guidelines for writing a review View our privacy policyFor Business Owners
Claim this business See inaccurate information? Submit an update here Link to this page from your site See an unfair review? View full terms & conditionsThis page has been viewed 0 times.