We planned a ferry layover in Tortola because of this place but it turned out the deli was closed on Sundays. We spent a fortune on store items to cobble a meal together: plain raw tofu and salad dressing on gluten-free bread, which was disappointing. But the deli menu looked really good and very reasonably priced. We'll definitely come back here when the deli is open. This place is run by Seventh Day Adventists, it was interesting as an atheist to be grateful for them and Rastas for making veg options available in the Virgin Islands.
Cons: deli closed on Sunday