I was pleasantly surprised when I visited here in June 2012. Ultimately, I accepted the recommendation of the friendly owner and was not disappointed. There is an extensive choice of veggie items (to be expected) and they were willing to cook to order for me.
The Lassi was also made to order (thankfully not one of those god-awful pre-made ultra sweet mango Lassis).
The owner could tell I was from the UK just because I ordered a roti with my meal, rather than a nan bread (which, apparently, us Limeys are prone to do!)
One of the best Indian meals I've had in the US which, sadly can be, to be kind, can be "patchy".
This place is tucked in the corner of a small shopping centre called South Side Station and my Sat Nav almost missed it. The car park was full but there were few customers patronising this place when I visited.
Cons: Easily missable