Mellow Mushroom has become a go-to wherever I am in the Southeast. The location on my new island home is no exception. Build your own pizza, calzone, or salad with a plethora of choices, including Daiya cheese. Usually, if you say the word "vegan," they know to leave the butter-brush & parmesan off the crust, but it doesn't hurt to be in the know when ordering. This is the best place for craft beer in HHI, for sure. The island twist on the psychedelic theme is nice. And the staff is exceptional: each server is consistently thorough, and when a mistake (in the vegan department) was made, they (a) identified it prior to serving it and (b) bought a round of drinks to compensate the wait. Round this out with weekly specials, locals night, and trivia, and it's a fave. Sure, as a Jersey girl, it's different than NJ/NY pizza crust, but it's still good, good food.
Cons: soft crust