We've had dinner here several times now and the food is always superb. The vegan tacos are out of this world. Great atmosphere, great food, it's our favorite restaurant on the island by far.
Wish there were more vegan options, especially desserts.
Update (July 2015): Sometime in the last year, Fresh Taqueria has moved to a mandatory gratuity system in addition to higher prices. We had a party of 6 and the mandatory gratuity was over 20%. The waitstaff was nice enough, but we didn't even get a water refill at any point during the dinner. Though we always tip well, this definitely was not a 20%+ tip situation. The food was as good as always, but given the expense, we'll probably stay in and make our own tacos next time.
Updated from previous review on Thursday June 26, 2014
Cons: mandatory gratuity